Re: Moving to bin/solr start defaulting to SolrCloud mode?

2024-10-03 Thread David Smiley
Pluggability of ZK is a separate topic and you'll find it contentious since IMO it's a complete fantasy -- a massive effort for so little payoff. So let's not bring that up in this thread. Anyway, your last paragraph is the key part, and I agree but we're not there yet. Changing the default is c

Re: Some tests failing 100%

2024-10-03 Thread Gus Heck
The failures I saw when I downloaded a couple logs centered on threads not terminated. Perhaps Uwe's box is so overloaded that the shutdown process for those tests takes too long and the test fails instead? On Thu, Oct 3, 2024 at 3:47 PM David Smiley wrote: > Relying on people to go look at CI o

Re: Some tests failing 100%

2024-10-03 Thread David Smiley
Relying on people to go look at CI out of the goodness of our hearts is a losing strategy. Our contributors don't even know where that is! There needs to be a trigger to do so ideally something personalized -- a build failure with recent changes that *you* included. Or instead a post/comment on

Re: Some tests failing 100%

2024-10-03 Thread Houston Putman
The failures generally seem to be coming from Uwe's boxes, and I cannot reproduce them locally. The crossDc ones do seem to be failing a lot, but when they fail, it looks like they aren't failing alone. I will continue to do research on it though. Our tests are extremely flakey right now, so it's

Some tests failing 100%

2024-10-03 Thread Gus Heck
I went to the fucit jenkins reports site to check on the state of the build after my recent commit to make sure all was well, but when I got there I was greeted with several weeks of extremely frequent test failures and in the last 2 weeks we seem to have gained several 100% failures (that clearly

Re: Moving to bin/solr start defaulting to SolrCloud mode?

2024-10-03 Thread Eric Pugh
I am continuing to think about this.. Thanks David for reminding us on https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SOLR-17468 about this thread. To uwe's point, someday we'll need to take what ZooKeeper does and make it pluggable. For a single node Solr, it could be just a Hashmap that supports th