Re: SolrJ collection creation API, replica type specificity

2024-05-03 Thread David Smiley
I totally understand that the client should be empowered to be specific, and it is right now. But I also think we should support the client being unspecific, and instead allow Solr service owners via Solr-side configuration to choose what makes sense. Where I work, there are different teams betwe

Re: SolrJ collection creation API, replica type specificity

2024-05-03 Thread Jason Gerlowski
You didn't mention it by name, but it sounds like you're talking about the v1 API's "replicationFactor" parameter (which has defaulted to creating NRT replicas for awhile now)? Personally, I'd rather see that parameter (and corresponding SolrJ code) go away altogether. Some things (e.g. the confi

Re: PRS, important changes needed

2024-05-03 Thread Justin Sweeney
I've got an umbrella Jira started here: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SOLR-17270. Feel free to add into it as anyone comes across things. On Fri, May 3, 2024 at 12:10 PM Cassandra Targett wrote: > I haven’t followed what PRS even is or what its benefits are supposed to > be so can’t com

Re: PRS, important changes needed

2024-05-03 Thread Cassandra Targett
I haven’t followed what PRS even is or what its benefits are supposed to be so can’t comment on whether it should/coud be a default. I may be alone in that since I haven’t had bandwidth to pay attention to very many recent Solr changes, but I do note that there is only one entry in the Solr Ref Gu