Re: JAX-RS APIs in Solr

2021-12-03 Thread Gus Heck
+1 to pretty much everything Tim said, especially not re-inventing wheels. Let's use the light weight drop forged aluminum ones that come with steel belted tubeless radials from the store, not the ones we carve out of our own block of rubber attached to a bit of steel plate with assorted screws. We

Re: JAX-RS APIs in Solr

2021-12-03 Thread Timothy Potter
Why do we keep talking about Restlet here? Restlet is a stale (at best) project, so not sure why it keeps coming up in a discussion about modernizing our API? Integration with it in Solr was introduced nearly 10 years ago, time to move on and stop using that as an excuse to block adoption of other

Re: Re: Unuseful block of code in ltr module

2021-12-03 Thread Alessandro Benedetti
adding in the loop Diego and Christine as potentially they are not in the list yet. -- Alessandro Benedetti Apache Lucene/Solr Committer Director, R&D Software Engineer, Search Consultant www.sease.io On Fri, 3 Dec 2021 at 15:24, Anna Ruggero wrote: > Hi Diego, > Thank

RE: Re: Unuseful block of code in ltr module

2021-12-03 Thread Anna Ruggero
Hi Diego, Thank you for your reply. >From what I've seen the topN variable takes the value from the rerankDocs parameter passed at query time. I've tried to pass different values for the rerankDocs and topN seems always to reflect this. Also in these cases, hits.length was always equal to topN. It

Re: First class support for node roles

2021-12-03 Thread Gus Heck
I really don't think we should have types of roles. Not negative/positive and not strict/non-strict. You have a role or you don't. What that means is up to the code implementing the role. Roles should be free to configure a preference order (binary, or n-ary or whatever, strict or loose), prohibit