Re: Solr and Jetty and Servlets

2021-08-16 Thread Mark Miller
The downside to respecting web.xml and making JettySolrServer serve a webapp is that loading a webapp is very expensive and slow in comparison. JettySolrServer actually starts up extremely quickly. It’s almost more appealing to change the Server to use the JettySolrServer strategy. It’s so slow to

Re: Solr and Jetty and Servlets

2021-08-16 Thread Gus Heck
So I'm not interested in *adhering* to anything here, just using stuff where it helps... I see tools sitting on the shelf, already bought and paid for and carried with us to every job but then they sit in the back of the truck mostly unused... and (I think) they look useful. This should not be see

Re: Solr and Jetty and Servlets

2021-08-16 Thread David Smiley
Sounds like an interesting adventure last weekend. I'm unclear what the point of going this direction is; my instinct is to go the opposite direction. You seem to suggest there are some simplification/organization benefits, which I love, so I'll need to look at what you've done to judge that for

Solr and Jetty and Servlets

2021-08-16 Thread Gus Heck
*TLDR:* I've got a working branch where CoreContainer & our startup process is extracted from SolrDispatch Filter. Do other folks think that is interesting enough that I should make a JIRA and/or PR with intention to make this change? *Details:*