Re: SolrCloud Alone: Deprecate Standalone Mode

2021-08-09 Thread Houston Putman
I agree with David that the first step would be to make SolrCloud the default mode. I made a dev list thread about this a few months ago, but I think I failed to respond at some point. I will get back on that and address the I also really like Mike's idea that we enable very similar use cases with

Re: SolrCloud Alone: Deprecate Standalone Mode

2021-08-09 Thread David Smiley
Given that SolrCloud is not even the default mode, I think it is premature to deprecate standalone mode. Let's do this first and maybe consider deprecating standalone after some time? ~ David Smiley Apache Lucene/Solr Search Developer http://www.linkedin.com/in/davidwsmiley On Mon, Aug 9, 2021

Re: SolrCloud Alone: Deprecate Standalone Mode

2021-08-09 Thread Mike Drob
Could we simulate user managed replication with an embedded zookeeper on the primary and pull replicas on the followers? On Mon, Aug 9, 2021 at 12:56 PM Jason Gerlowski wrote: > > Hey Marcus, > > The places I've worked in the past have all used SolrCloud primarily > so I can't speak to any specif

Re: SolrCloud Alone: Deprecate Standalone Mode

2021-08-09 Thread Jason Gerlowski
Hey Marcus, The places I've worked in the past have all used SolrCloud primarily so I can't speak to any specifics, but my impression from reading user-list traffic is that a sizable chunk of Solr's user base prefers "User-Managed" mode (formerly called "standalone"). Some because they don't want

Re: The Solr Benchmark Module is targeted for commit next week

2021-08-09 Thread Jason Gerlowski
Thanks for the info! The Zeppelin stuff in particular piques my interest: I explored a Zeppelin/Solr integration a bit in SOLR-15080, but ultimately never committed it because of some lukewarm feedback from David S on the PR and some shifting personal priorities. If others are using Zeppelin mayb