RE: Why is build.properties from ${user.home} the most dominant

2003-09-21 Thread Brett Porter
I think I actually agree with Colin here. ~/build.properties as a default; ${basedir}/build.properties as an override. I actually use ~/build.properties to set things that don't happen to be set later, so it won't impact, but one way to have it go forward is to leave ~/build.properties as is, and h

Re: Why is build.properties from ${user.home} the most dominant

2003-09-21 Thread Colin Sampaleanu
Jason van Zyl wrote: On Sat, 2003-09-20 at 15:41, Colin Sampaleanu wrote: I wanted to get the rationale as to why build.properties from ${user.home} is more dominant than build.properties and project.properties from the project dir. To provide a final place where all values can be overri

RE: Why is build.properties from ${user.home} the most dominant

2003-09-21 Thread Michal Maczka
> -Original Message- > From: Rafal Krzewski [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: Sunday, September 21, 2003 3:43 PM > To: Maven Developers List > Subject: Re: Why is build.properties from ${user.home} the most dominant > > > [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > > >

Re: Why is build.properties from ${user.home} the most dominant

2003-09-21 Thread Rafal Krzewski
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The idea is that the user knows what he wants, not the project builder. I thought that the difference between project.properties and build.properties was the the former were created by the project's vendor and the latter by the person who is building the project and are s

Re: Why is build.properties from ${user.home} the most dominant

2003-09-21 Thread dion
Colin Sampaleanu <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote on 21/09/2003 05:41:06 AM: > I wanted to get the rationale as to why build.properties from > ${user.home} is more dominant than build.properties and > project.properties from the project dir. These are the users preferences, regardless of any project p

Re: Why is build.properties from ${user.home} the most dominant

2003-09-21 Thread Rafal Krzewski
Jason van Zyl wrote: I wanted to get the rationale as to why build.properties from ${user.home} is more dominant than build.properties and project.properties from the project dir. From my experience, it is indeed a problem when you need to make a system specific override for a set of related pro

Re: Why is build.properties from ${user.home} the most dominant

2003-09-20 Thread Jason van Zyl
On Sat, 2003-09-20 at 15:41, Colin Sampaleanu wrote: > I wanted to get the rationale as to why build.properties from > ${user.home} is more dominant than build.properties and > project.properties from the project dir. To provide a final place where all values can be overridden. The asumption bei

Why is build.properties from ${user.home} the most dominant

2003-09-20 Thread Colin Sampaleanu
I wanted to get the rationale as to why build.properties from ${user.home} is more dominant than build.properties and project.properties from the project dir. This has always seemed ass-backwards to me, and is in fact backwards to the order in which a number of ant projects I've seen (and mine)