+1
On Nov 8, 2014, at 9:52 AM, Kristian Rosenvold
wrote:
> We had a lot of trolling about not deleting git tags; but I think they
> all left us. Personally it seems to me like it does not really matter
> all that much; and I'm still here :)
>
> if you rewrite a tag it will be updated once you
We had a lot of trolling about not deleting git tags; but I think they
all left us. Personally it seems to me like it does not really matter
all that much; and I'm still here :)
if you rewrite a tag it will be updated once you refresh from the
remote. There is a danger some replication settings ma
IMO you never delete a tag that has a VOTE associated with it.
Gary
Original message From: Mirko Friedenhagen
Date:11/08/2014 07:15 (GMT-05:00)
To: Maven Developers List Subject:
Stance on patch releases
Hello,
now that I canceled the vote on maven-pmd-plugin 3.3
I'm not a git expert, then my explanations are to be confirmed
>From what I understood, there is no problem on canonical ASF repo not github
mirror. The problem is for people who cloned the repo or updated their clone
with initial tag: they don't get the tag update unless they manually delete
t
If you haven't pushed the tag, it is perfectly safe to delete and
recreate it. If you did push, however, the new tag will have to be
propagated manually in each and every clone. You can find more details
in [1], look for "On Re-tagging" section.
Even without git, I find artifacts with the same ve
Hi,
On 11/8/14 1:21 PM, Hervé BOUTEMY wrote:
for svn, in the past, we've deleted and reused the tag
but the release manager decides if he wants to create a new tag: it doesn't
hurt
for git, we've seen deleting a tag is not really possible in a safe way, so
there is only one solution
Hmare t
I would just respin the release with version 3.3. With Subversion it's not
that big a deal to delete a tag (with a proper comment) and recreate it for
the re-spin.
With git it would be a big no-no to replace an already pushed tag, that's
why I create the final tag only after the vote completed and
Hi Mirco,
I i had to cancel a vote i have deleted the tag, cause it does not made
it to the real public and recreated after fixing the problem...
Based on staging you have the choice of going back
Kind regards
Karl Heinz Marbaise
-
for svn, in the past, we've deleted and reused the tag
but the release manager decides if he wants to create a new tag: it doesn't
hurt
for git, we've seen deleting a tag is not really possible in a safe way, so
there is only one solution
Regards,
Hervé
Le samedi 8 novembre 2014 13:15:21 Mirk
Hello,
now that I canceled the vote on maven-pmd-plugin 3.3 should I go for 3.3.1
or _delete_ and _reuse_ the tag. Or may the release responsible decide this
on his own? I am always in favor of creating a new tag.
Regards
Mirko
--
Sent from my mobile
10 matches
Mail list logo
