Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-24 Thread Carlos Sanchez
my very late vote :(, altough it's not needed [X] +1 for the full proposal - collapse all groups (implies a vote for the next option if vote doesn't pass) On 1/23/07, Brett Porter <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Yah, I sent a follow up mail acknowledging this and to the effect of "go nuts, but don't

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-23 Thread Brett Porter
Yah, I sent a follow up mail acknowledging this and to the effect of "go nuts, but don't go crazy" :) - Brett On 24/01/2007, at 2:02 PM, Rahul Thakur wrote: Is this formalized then? Rahul Brett Porter wrote: After the allotted 72 hours, the results stand as: Full proposal: 9 (7 PMC, 2 c

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-23 Thread Rahul Thakur
Is this formalized then? Rahul Brett Porter wrote: After the allotted 72 hours, the results stand as: Full proposal: 9 (7 PMC, 2 committers): Brett, Arnaud, Emmanuel, Trygve, Dennis, Fabrizio, Lukas, Rahul, Milos Partial proposal: 6 (6 PMC): Joakim, John T, Kenney, Jesse, John C, Jason Abst

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-12 Thread Vincent Massol
+0 for me (a bit late) -Vincent On 1/12/07, Brett Porter <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: After the allotted 72 hours, the results stand as: Full proposal: 9 (7 PMC, 2 committers): Brett, Arnaud, Emmanuel, Trygve, Dennis, Fabrizio, Lukas, Rahul, Milos Partial proposal: 6 (6 PMC): Joakim, John T, Ken

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-11 Thread Brett Porter
After the allotted 72 hours, the results stand as: Full proposal: 9 (7 PMC, 2 committers): Brett, Arnaud, Emmanuel, Trygve, Dennis, Fabrizio, Lukas, Rahul, Milos Partial proposal: 6 (6 PMC): Joakim, John T, Kenney, Jesse, John C, Jason Abstained: 3 (3 PMC): Mike, Vincent S, Stephane Against:

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-11 Thread Jason van Zyl
On 8 Jan 07, at 7:04 PM 8 Jan 07, Jason van Zyl wrote: -1 I change mine to: [X ] +1 for the partial proposal - retain subproject access restrictions I just want at the sub-project level. On 8 Jan 07, at 6:50 PM 8 Jan 07, Brett Porter wrote: Hi, Since there was no objection to calling

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-11 Thread Andrew Williams
-0 it might be nice to have access to everything once you join, but it seems handy to have an acl of all those writing to the various areas. On 8 Jan 2007, at 23:50, Brett Porter wrote: Hi, Since there was no objection to calling a vote, as discussed in the proposal, I'd like to call a vot

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-11 Thread Lukas Theussl
[x] +1 for the full proposal - collapse all groups (implies a vote for the next option if vote doesn't pass) -Lukas - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-10 Thread Fabrizio Giustina
[X] +1 for the full proposal - collapse all groups (implies a vote for the next option if vote doesn't pass) I think that anybody that got a committer status in any of the maven subproject should at least be considered enough smart to understand by himself if he has enough knowledge and confidenc

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-10 Thread John Casey
+1 for the partial proposal, retaining subproject access restrictions. On 1/10/07, Jesse McConnell <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: [X] +1 for the partial proposal - retain subproject access restrictions On 1/9/07, John Tolentino <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Brett Porter wrote: > > [ ] +1 for the

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-10 Thread Jesse McConnell
[X] +1 for the partial proposal - retain subproject access restrictions On 1/9/07, John Tolentino <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Brett Porter wrote: > [ ] +1 for the full proposal - collapse all groups (implies a vote for > the next option if vote doesn't pass) > [X] +1 for the partial proposal -

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-09 Thread John Tolentino
Brett Porter wrote: [ ] +1 for the full proposal - collapse all groups (implies a vote for the next option if vote doesn't pass) [X] +1 for the partial proposal - retain subproject access restrictions [ ] 0 abstain from vote [ ] -1 do not alter the current permissions ---

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-09 Thread Dennis Lundberg
Brett Porter wrote: [X] +1 for the full proposal - collapse all groups (implies a vote for the next option if vote doesn't pass) [ ] +1 for the partial proposal - retain subproject access restrictions [ ] 0 abstain from vote [ ] -1 do not alter the current permissions Cheers, Brett -- Denn

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-09 Thread Kenney Westerhof
Brett Porter wrote: [(re)moved parts of original mail:] [ ] +1 for the full proposal - collapse all groups (implies a vote for the next option if vote doesn't pass) [X] +1 for the partial proposal - retain subproject access restrictions [ ] 0 abstain from vote [ ] -1 do not alter the current

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-09 Thread Joakim Erdfelt
[ ] +1 for the full proposal - collapse all groups (implies a vote for the next option if vote doesn't pass) [X] +1 for the partial proposal - retain subproject access restrictions [ ] 0 abstain from vote [ ] -1 do not alter the current permissions

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-09 Thread Stephane Nicoll
+0 Stéphane On 1/9/07, Brett Porter <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Hi, Since there was no objection to calling a vote, as discussed in the proposal, I'd like to call a vote on this. To see the proposal and discussion: http://mail-archives.apache.org/ mod_mbox/maven-dev/200612.mbox/%3c67FC84B5-451

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-09 Thread Vincent Siveton
+0 Vincent 2007/1/8, Brett Porter <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: Hi, Since there was no objection to calling a vote, as discussed in the proposal, I'd like to call a vote on this. To see the proposal and discussion: http://mail-archives.apache.org/ mod_mbox/maven-dev/200612.mbox/%3c67FC84B5-4510-469B-A

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-09 Thread Milos Kleint
+1 on the collapsing of access groups Milos On 1/9/07, Brett Porter <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Hi, Since there was no objection to calling a vote, as discussed in the proposal, I'd like to call a vote on this. To see the proposal and discussion: http://mail-archives.apache.org/ mod_mbox/maven

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-09 Thread Trygve Laugstøl
Brett Porter wrote: Hi, Since there was no objection to calling a vote, as discussed in the proposal, I'd like to call a vote on this. To see the proposal and discussion: http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/maven-dev/200612.mbox/[EMAIL PROTECTED] Vote to operate as - requiring 2/3rd

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-09 Thread Emmanuel Venisse
+1 with same comment. I don't think committers that don't know enough a project will commit on it except for basic patches. Emmanuel Arnaud HERITIER a écrit : [ X ] +1 for the full proposal - collapse all groups (implies a vote for the next option if vote doesn't pass) We are all enough adul

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-08 Thread Rahul Thakur
+1 for the full proposal - collapse all groups (implies a vote for the next option if vote doesn't pass) Rahul Brett Porter wrote: On 09/01/2007, at 10:50 AM, Brett Porter wrote: [X] +1 for the full proposal - collapse all groups (implies a vote for the next option if vote doesn't pass)

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-08 Thread Brett Porter
On 09/01/2007, at 10:50 AM, Brett Porter wrote: [X] +1 for the full proposal - collapse all groups (implies a vote for the next option if vote doesn't pass) [ ] +1 for the partial proposal - retain subproject access restrictions [ ] 0 abstain from vote [ ] -1 do not alter the current permis

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-08 Thread Arnaud HERITIER
[ X ] +1 for the full proposal - collapse all groups (implies a vote for the next option if vote doesn't pass) We are all enough adult to know what we can(not) do. And everything is stored in an SCM thus we can remove any error introduced by someone else. Arnaud On 1/9/07, Brett Porter <[EMAIL

Re: [vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-08 Thread Jason van Zyl
-1 On 8 Jan 07, at 6:50 PM 8 Jan 07, Brett Porter wrote: Hi, Since there was no objection to calling a vote, as discussed in the proposal, I'd like to call a vote on this. To see the proposal and discussion: http://mail-archives.apache.org/ mod_mbox/maven-dev/200612.mbox/%3c67FC84B5-4510-

[vote] Collapse Maven permission groups

2007-01-08 Thread Brett Porter
Hi, Since there was no objection to calling a vote, as discussed in the proposal, I'd like to call a vote on this. To see the proposal and discussion: http://mail-archives.apache.org/ mod_mbox/maven-dev/200612.mbox/%3c67FC84B5-4510-469B-AEC1- [EMAIL PROTECTED] Vote to operate as - requiri