Re: [DISCUSS] Maven3 and Maven4 support split

2024-05-06 Thread Tamás Cservenák
Romain, You can look at this change (which I did, for plugin testing) just like resolver-1.9.x branch: a "stable" release of testing for 3.x plugins is very desperately needed. Same thing for maven-plugin-plugin. So yes, this is kinda the b) option: a Maven4 plugin cannot be built (m-p-p or tested

Re: [DISCUSS] Maven3 and Maven4 support split

2024-05-06 Thread Romain Manni-Bucau
Hi Tamas, If the impact is to prevent to build a maven 3 (original setup version or CI version for ex) with maven 4 (local version for ex) then I think it violates the contract we had for maven 4 and I'd really like it to not happen. If it is the opposite (a maven 4 based/native project can't be r

[DISCUSS] Maven3 and Maven4 support split

2024-05-06 Thread Tamás Cservenák
Howdy, my pain point was plugin-testing-harness 3.3.0 that is really ancient, while master of it was mixing maven3 and maven4 support... so I went to split things. IMO we need to split (like maven-3.x and master branch) for maven 3 and maven 4 support, as there is really no need to support "both"