Re: Switch Log4j to GitHub Issues

2022-11-07 Thread Volkan Yazıcı
Great questions Ralph! Let me address them: > Can we continue to use changes.xml? I propose switching to a custom changelog configuration. See LOG4J2-3628 that I have just created. > How are we going to handle issues already in Jira? I say let

Re: Switch Log4j to GitHub Issues

2022-11-05 Thread Xeno Amess
AM To: Apache Logging Developers List Subject: Re: Switch Log4j to GitHub Issues What I like best about switching to GitHub is dealing with fewer or zero spam tickets. I will also relay that I've had push back in the past from folks who refuse to get a GitHub account in order to provide PR

Re: Switch Log4j to GitHub Issues

2022-11-05 Thread Gary Gregory
What I like best about switching to GitHub is dealing with fewer or zero spam tickets. I will also relay that I've had push back in the past from folks who refuse to get a GitHub account in order to provide PRs. I have no idea how we can integrate changes.xml with GitHub, maybe that's something t

Re: Switch Log4j to GitHub Issues

2022-11-04 Thread Ralph Goers
I’d like to know how we can get GitHub issue links included into the release info. Can we continue to use changes.xml? How are we going to handle issues already in Jira? We currently have 898 open issues. My guess is we will be lucky to ever get to 10% of them. But how do we lock down Jira whi

Re: Switch Log4j to GitHub Issues

2022-11-04 Thread Matt Sicker
Usage on a phone is certainly a nice advantage for GH. Same with the MFA integration, though the ASF is working on integrating MFA with the rest of their offered services over time. And it does make it easier for users to submit issues now that Jira is restricted. We might want some method for

Re: Switch Log4j to GitHub Issues

2022-11-04 Thread Carter Kozak
I’m supportive of using GitHub issues for a few reasons: It’s more inclusive to our users who can no longer create jira accounts. My account is more secure, requiring hardware tokens to log in. Unlike jira, it renders correctly on my phone. -ck > On Nov 4, 2022, at 09:43, Matt Sicker wrote: > >

Re: Switch Log4j to GitHub Issues

2022-11-04 Thread Matt Sicker
I’m fairly neutral on the change. At least you can reply to GitHub Issue emails and have them added to the conversation (like with PRs). We don’t really use any fancy Jira features that aren’t also available in GitHub. > On Nov 4, 2022, at 9:06 AM, Volkan Yazıcı wrote: > > Given the last updat