Re: About Geode rolling downgrade

2020-06-12 Thread Alberto Gomez
Hi Naba! Did you manage to comment this topic with some engineers? Cheers, /Alberto G. From: Nabarun Nag Sent: Friday, June 5, 2020 11:00 AM To: dev@geode.apache.org Subject: Re: About Geode rolling downgrade Hi Mario and Alberto, I will sync up with couple

Re: About Geode rolling downgrade

2020-06-05 Thread Nabarun Nag
shutdown the new version DS. Now we have a DS with lower version. Regards Naba From: Mario Ivanac Sent: Friday, June 5, 2020 1:19:42 AM To: geode Subject: Odg: About Geode rolling downgrade Hi all, just a reminder that Alberto is still waiting for feedback

Odg: About Geode rolling downgrade

2020-06-05 Thread Mario Ivanac
Hi all, just a reminder that Alberto is still waiting for feedback, regarding his question. BR, Mario Å alje: Alberto Gomez Poslano: 14. svibnja 2020. 14:45 Prima: geode Predmet: Re: About Geode rolling downgrade Hi, I friendly reminder to the community about

Re: About Geode rolling downgrade

2020-05-14 Thread Alberto Gomez
Hi, I friendly reminder to the community about this request for feedback. Thanks, -Alberto G. From: Alberto Gomez Sent: Thursday, May 7, 2020 10:44 AM To: geode Subject: Re: About Geode rolling downgrade Hi again, Considering Geode does not support online

Re: About Geode rolling downgrade

2020-05-07 Thread Alberto Gomez
if it holds in this rollback case. Best regards, -Alberto G. From: Anilkumar Gingade Sent: Thursday, April 23, 2020 12:59 AM To: geode Subject: Re: About Geode rolling downgrade That's right, most/always no down-time requirement is managed by h

Re: About Geode rolling downgrade

2020-04-22 Thread Anilkumar Gingade
That's right, most/always no down-time requirement is managed by having replicated cluster setups (Disaster-recovery/backup site). The data is either pushed to both systems through the data ingesters or by using WAN setup. The clusters are upgraded one at a time. If there is a failure during upgrad

Re: About Geode rolling downgrade

2020-04-22 Thread Anthony Baker
Anil, let me see if I understand your perspective by stating it this way: If cases where 100% uptime is a requirement, users are almost always running a disaster recovery site. It could be active/active or active/standby but there are already at least 2 clusters with current copies of the data.

Re: About Geode rolling downgrade

2020-04-22 Thread Anilkumar Gingade
ped for > the > > rolling upgrade. > > > > Anyhow, we wonder what would be as of today the recommended or official > > way to downgrade a Geode system without downtime and data loss? > > > > > > > > From: Bruce Schuchard

Re: About Geode rolling downgrade

2020-04-21 Thread Dan Smith
) will have been developed for the > rolling upgrade. > > Anyhow, we wonder what would be as of today the recommended or official > way to downgrade a Geode system without downtime and data loss? > > > > From: Bruce Schuchardt > Sent: Frid

Re: About Geode rolling downgrade

2020-04-20 Thread alberto.gomez
From: Bruce Schuchardt Sent: Friday, April 17, 2020 11:36 PM To: dev@geode.apache.org Subject: Re: About Geode rolling downgrade Hi Alberto, I think that if we want to support limited rolling downgrade some other version interchange needs to be done and there need to be tests that prove

Re: About Geode rolling downgrade

2020-04-17 Thread Bruce Schuchardt
y. -Alberto From: Bruce Schuchardt Sent: Thursday, April 16, 2020 5:04 PM To: dev@geode.apache.org Subject: Re: About Geode rolling downgrade -1 Another reason that we should not support rolling downgrade is that it ma

Re: About Geode rolling downgrade

2020-04-17 Thread Alberto Gomez
Geode rolling downgrade -1 Another reason that we should not support rolling downgrade is that it makes it impossible to upgrade distributed algorithms. When we added rolling upgrade support we pretty much immediately ran into a distributed hang when a test started a Locator using an older version

Re: About Geode rolling downgrade

2020-04-16 Thread Bruce Schuchardt
-1 Another reason that we should not support rolling downgrade is that it makes it impossible to upgrade distributed algorithms. When we added rolling upgrade support we pretty much immediately ran into a distributed hang when a test started a Locator using an older version. In that release w

About Geode rolling downgrade

2020-04-16 Thread Alberto Gomez
Hi, Some months ago I posted a question on this list (see [1]) about the possibility of supporting "rolling downgrade" in Geode in order to downgrade a Geode system to an older version, similar to the "rolling upgrade" currently supported. With your answers and my investigations my conclusion w