Re: On Codes of Conduct

2016-11-16 Thread William A Rowe Jr
On Nov 17, 2016 04:03, "Noah Slater" wrote: > > He offered to copy the email to the list in the reply I was responding to. Not directed toward you, but I had thought to bring this up a week or so earlier when I first read their article and other hostile email traffic, and the welcome plenary at A

Re: On Codes of Conduct

2016-11-16 Thread Noah Slater
He offered to copy the email to the list in the reply I was responding to. :) I can't resist pointing out the irony of you flagging my conduct on a public list, in an email thread you started to criticise me for flagging someones conduct on the same list. ;) Also, I want to challenge your charact

Re: On Codes of Conduct

2016-11-16 Thread William A Rowe Jr
I think you misinterpreted a couple things... On Nov 17, 2016 02:18, "Noah Slater" wrote:. > > I quoted a chunk of an email that was sent to me privately because the > person who sent it had already offered to copy it to the list. I saved him > the trouble by excerpting the bit I wanted to remark

Re: On Codes of Conduct

2016-11-16 Thread Noah Slater
The thread you're referencing contains a number of actionable, productive suggestions. Indeed, mine and other's participation on that thread was an attempt to counteract derailment. I quoted a chunk of an email that was sent to me privately because the person who sent it had already offered to cop

On Codes of Conduct

2016-11-16 Thread William A Rowe Jr
So I just sort of boggled at an post that seemed to quote private correspondence while making a CoC accusation, or at least that's what I think I read. Many of us know the holidays for the airing of grievances arrives in 2 months, but public archived email lists really are simply not the place. We