Re: [PROPOSAL] give wiki write access to any existing ASF committer

2009-12-06 Thread Isabel Drost
On Friday 04 December 2009 21:16:32 Ross Gardler wrote: > I don't believe this is a good idea in the long term, or even medium > term, as freely edited wikis usually result in chaos and incomplete > articles. I don't know whether more restrictive access control prevents that from happening. I th

Re: [PROPOSAL] give wiki write access to any existing ASF committer

2009-12-04 Thread Luciano Resende
On Fri, Dec 4, 2009 at 3:40 PM, Ross Gardler wrote: > 2009/12/4 Luciano Resende : >> On Fri, Dec 4, 2009 at 2:22 PM, Kathey Marsden >> wrote: >>> Ross Gardler wrote: We've not really discussed who should have access to the comdev resources. I'd like to propose that, in the short te

Re: [PROPOSAL] give wiki write access to any existing ASF committer

2009-12-04 Thread Ross Gardler
2009/12/4 Luciano Resende : > On Fri, Dec 4, 2009 at 2:22 PM, Kathey Marsden > wrote: >> Ross Gardler wrote: >>> >>> We've not really discussed who should have access to the comdev >>> resources. I'd like to propose that, in the short term, we grant write >>> access to anyone who has earned commit

Re: [PROPOSAL] give wiki write access to any existing ASF committer

2009-12-04 Thread Luciano Resende
On Fri, Dec 4, 2009 at 2:22 PM, Kathey Marsden wrote: > Ross Gardler wrote: >> >> We've not really discussed who should have access to the comdev >> resources. I'd like to propose that, in the short term, we grant write >> access to anyone who has earned committership on any project in the >> ASF

Re: [PROPOSAL] give wiki write access to any existing ASF committer

2009-12-04 Thread Kathey Marsden
Ross Gardler wrote: We've not really discussed who should have access to the comdev resources. I'd like to propose that, in the short term, we grant write access to anyone who has earned committership on any project in the ASF (including incubating projects). I think it is fine and just post a

Re: [PROPOSAL] give wiki write access to any existing ASF committer

2009-12-04 Thread Benson Margulies
I like this. It's a way to suck in people with useful information to contribute. Later, as you say, some trimming will reduce the number of wandering fragmentary contributions. On Fri, Dec 4, 2009 at 3:16 PM, Ross Gardler wrote: > We've not really discussed who should have access to the comdev >

[PROPOSAL] give wiki write access to any existing ASF committer

2009-12-04 Thread Ross Gardler
We've not really discussed who should have access to the comdev resources. I'd like to propose that, in the short term, we grant write access to anyone who has earned committership on any project in the ASF (including incubating projects). My reasoning is that we need to generate (and collate) cle