Re: Reviewing the evaluation process

2010-04-22 Thread Ted Dunning
I should add that our community is very active (occasionally even aggressive) in providing feedback for ideas whether or not they came in as part of GSoC. As we see it, the Summer of Code is just a one reason to contribute among many others (a hobby, a full time job, religious commitment to a lear

Re: Reviewing the evaluation process

2010-04-22 Thread Grant Ingersoll
On Apr 22, 2010, at 12:14 PM, Ted Dunning wrote: > On the other hand, this has been the single criterion that has defined > successful students in Mahout (which is definitely less standards driven). > > In Derby and similar projects, I think that this can be interpreted > differently, but it sti

Re: Reviewing the evaluation process

2010-04-22 Thread Ted Dunning
On the other hand, this has been the single criterion that has defined successful students in Mahout (which is definitely less standards driven). In Derby and similar projects, I think that this can be interpreted differently, but it still is a useful ranking indicator. Within the set of Derby ap

Re: Reviewing the evaluation process

2010-04-22 Thread Kathey Marsden
On 4/22/2010 7:24 AM, Ross Gardler wrote: I'd like to make a few comments about issues that have arisen during the evaluation process for GSoC. I'm going to give my opinion on each, please treat this as lazy consensus - do speak up if you wish to disagree or add more items: Thank's Ross, A few

Reviewing the evaluation process

2010-04-22 Thread Ross Gardler
I'd like to make a few comments about issues that have arisen during the evaluation process for GSoC. I'm going to give my opinion on each, please treat this as lazy consensus - do speak up if you wish to disagree or add more items: Not enough visibility of the process

Re: London graduate events

2010-04-22 Thread Ross Gardler
Mark, I agree with your comments. With respect to: > If these events are to be successful, then I think we need to work on > continuity. We are thinking about getting students back, if we run the > event again with some of the same projects, so that past students may > learn more and also help

Re: London graduate events

2010-04-22 Thread Mark Hindess
[I've removed concom from the CC as my reply is less relevant to them.) In message <4bccbb5b.6000...@apache.org>, Ross Gardler writes: > > On Saturday I was at an event run by the Graduate Developer Community > in London. I'm dropping this here so that concom/comdev are aware of > some of the act