Re: About commons-net and GSoC

2009-04-03 Thread Rory Winston
Sergey The goal for this implementation is to add ssh/scp/sftp support to commons-net. I originally looked at integrating an existing SSH client implementation, but integration was not straightforward.. The Mina SSH implementation looks like a better implementation in terms of code quality and

Re: About commons-net and GSoC

2009-04-03 Thread Guillaume Nodet
If you're talking about the Mina Sshd project, the primay goal was to have an ASL friendly SSH server in Java wich I haven't found before beginning this project. The client part came later came naturally later because a lot of code is shared. But there' still a lot to do on this project (client ke

Re: About commons-net and GSoC

2009-04-03 Thread Sergey Vladimirov
Guys, stupid question So...why do we need a new, 4-th (3-rd BSD-style) full SSH implementation? :) -- Sergey On Fri, Apr 3, 2009 at 1:03 PM, Guillaume Nodet wrote: > The dependency is at scope test AFAIK and it's only used to do some > testing on the SSH server implementation. > > On Fri, Ap

Re: About commons-net and GSoC

2009-04-03 Thread Guillaume Nodet
The dependency is at scope test AFAIK and it's only used to do some testing on the SSH server implementation. On Fri, Apr 3, 2009 at 09:40, Rory Winston wrote: > Guillaume > > You're right - apologies, I just had a quick look at it and assumed it was > along the same lines as another SSH client f

Re: About commons-net and GSoC

2009-04-03 Thread Rory Winston
Guillaume You're right - apologies, I just had a quick look at it and assumed it was along the same lines as another SSH client framework that someone suggested earlier (which itself was just a wrapper). I also noticed mina-sshd has jsch in its dependency list - I wonder why it needs it if it

Re: About commons-net and GSoC

2009-04-02 Thread Guillaume Nodet
This is not a wrapper. It's a plain SSH server and client implementation based on NIO (using MINA) ... Anyway, if you are looking for something different, that's no big deal ... On Fri, Apr 3, 2009 at 00:56, Rory Winston wrote: > I've had a look at this - this is just an existing SSH implementat

Re: About commons-net and GSoC

2009-04-02 Thread Rory Winston
I've had a look at this - this is just an existing SSH implementation wrapper, which is not really what I had in mind. Thanks for the heads up though. Cheers Guillaume Nodet wrote: It has been brought to my attention that there is a proposal for GSoC about SSH/SCP support in commons-net. I ju

About commons-net and GSoC

2009-04-02 Thread Guillaume Nodet
It has been brought to my attention that there is a proposal for GSoC about SSH/SCP support in commons-net. I just want to point people towards the SSHD subproject in Mina which already implements SSH client and server support, along with SCP support on the server side. It may be interesting to reu