Re: List of serious issues fixed in 3.0.x

2020-05-18 Thread Oleksandr Petrov
Wanted to add some that I remembered: * https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CASSANDRA-12811 - data resurrection, but was marked as normal because was discovered with a test. Should've marked it as critical. * https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CASSANDRA-12956 - data loss (commit log isn't

Re: List of serious issues fixed in 3.0.x

2020-05-07 Thread Joshua McKenzie
"ML is plaintext bro" - thanks Mick. ಠ_ಠ Since we're stuck in the late 90's, here's some links to a gsheet: Defects by month: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Qt8lLIiqVvK7mlSML7zsmXdAc-LsvktFW5RXJDRtN8k/edit#gid=1584867240 Defects by component: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Qt8lL

Re: List of serious issues fixed in 3.0.x

2020-05-07 Thread Scott Andreas
4.0 release that users can trust and adopt quickly. – Scott From: Joshua McKenzie Sent: Thursday, May 7, 2020 9:31 AM Cc: dev@cassandra.apache.org Subject: Re: List of serious issues fixed in 3.0.x Hearing the images got killed by the web server. Trying from

Re: List of serious issues fixed in 3.0.x

2020-05-07 Thread Joshua McKenzie
Hearing the images got killed by the web server. Trying from gmail (sorry for spam). Time to see if it's the apache smtp server or the list culling images: --- I did a little analysis on this data (any defect marked with fixversion 4.0 that rose to the level

Re: List of serious issues fixed in 3.0.x

2020-05-07 Thread Joshua McKenzie
I did a little analysis on this data (any defect marked with fixversion 4.0 that rose to the level of critical in terms of availability, correctness, or corruption/loss) and charted some things the rest of the project community might find interesting: 1: Critical (availability, correctness, corrup

Re: List of serious issues fixed in 3.0.x

2020-05-06 Thread Dinesh Joshi
Hi Sankalp, Thanks for bringing this up. At the very minimum, I hope we have regression tests for the specific issues we have fixed. I personally think, the project should focus on building a comprehensive test suite. However, some of these issues can only be detected at scale. We need users t

List of serious issues fixed in 3.0.x

2020-05-06 Thread sankalp kohli
Hi, I want to share some of the serious issues that were found and fixed in 3.0.x. I have created this list from JIRA to help us identify areas for validating 4.0. This will also give an insight to the dev community. Let us know if anyone has suggestions on how to better use this data in vali