Re: Status of CEP-1

2024-11-16 Thread Dinesh Joshi
Hi all, I sincerely want to thank everyone who chimed in on this thread and the slack conversation. I want to make sure that I cover the background on CEP-1 for posterity's sake. Cassandra Sidecar was proposed as a component / sub-project prior to the existence of CEP. The discussion around this

Re: Status of CEP-1

2024-11-16 Thread Joseph Lynch
Just bringing this back to the list. Patrick, Francisco, Jon and I discussed this a bit over in slack [1] and I think we got to a rough consensus that: 1. We're going to leave CEP-1 archived, if someone calls out functionality in the current sidecar code they think is problematic we'll open a disc

Re: Status of CEP-1

2024-11-16 Thread Joseph Lynch
Oh I didn't agree we needed a new CEP, I thought we were agreeing on focusing on releasing the sidecar as is. CEP-1 was already voted on, we built consensus on the controversial part (having functionality outside the main process) and developers already started the project many years ago and teams

Re: Status of CEP-1

2024-11-16 Thread Josh McKenzie
> The process we all agreed to is being avoided, so I hope we can get back on > track here. Words matter. I don't think anyone is avoiding anything here, I think CEP-1 was a first draft, way too large, and it's been chaotic and confusing to transition from that to where we are now with a realist