Re: Welcome Berenguer Blasi as Cassandra committer

2021-03-28 Thread Berenguer Blasi
Thanks all. Really appreciate it :-) On 27/3/21 0:24, Lorina Poland wrote: > Just adding more congratulations, Berenguer! Well-deserved! > > Lorina Poland > e. lor...@datastax.com > w. www.datastax.com > > > > On Fri, Mar 26, 2021 at 12:17 PM Yifan Cai wrote: > >> Congratulations Berenguer! >> >>

Re: Download source release / binary files in source release

2021-03-28 Thread Benedict Elliott Smith
> This is not a retrospective change just a clarification on what should be > self evident. This is a non-sequitur surely? Can something that is self-evident need clarifying? Or do you suppose it is self-evident to all besides the feeble intellects of this community? I think a self-evident pol

Re: Download source release / binary files in source release

2021-03-28 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, > Given the same agreement there that the ASF's docs are unclear on the > topic, and having to rely upon a post from Roy in *some thread, I think it > is safe to say we can (if need be) continue until those docs are made up to > date. Also, I cannot see how the ASF can enforce anything retroac

Re: Download source release / binary files in source release

2021-03-28 Thread Mick Semb Wever
> > I thought you had indicated you were anyway raising this with the board? > > Either way, I don't personally see any issue with delaying the vote by a > week or so if it will bring some official clarity to this issue, now it has > been raised. How quickly can we expect to see changes reflected i

Re: Download source release / binary files in source release

2021-03-28 Thread Benedict Elliott Smith
I thought you had indicated you were anyway raising this with the board? Either way, I don't personally see any issue with delaying the vote by a week or so if it will bring some official clarity to this issue, now it has been raised. How quickly can we expect to see changes reflected in the off

Re: Download source release / binary files in source release

2021-03-28 Thread Justin Mclean
HI, > I recommend that the PMC continues its vote on 4.0-rc1. In that case I'll need to raise this issue with theASF board. Justin - To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@cassandra.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail:

Re: Download source release / binary files in source release

2021-03-28 Thread Mick Semb Wever
> I can only speak for myself, but I am happy to ensure future releases > follow this policy once it is clearly stated as an official ASF policy by > the official policy documentation. > +1 I recommend that the PMC continues its vote on 4.0-rc1. With the understanding that the ASF updates the p

Re: Download source release / binary files in source release

2021-03-28 Thread Benedict Elliott Smith
> I guess you are asking for something official from VP Legal Affairs or the > ASF board? If so I can make that happen. I would prefer the official policy pages to be updated to have a clear statement on this, so this problem can be solved in perpetuity. > IMO it does, the project can choose to

Re: Download source release / binary files in source release

2021-03-28 Thread Justin Mclean
Hi, > You are probably right, but as far as I am aware you are not an official > source of ASF policy on this matter. I am currently assistant VP legal affairs and have made changes to ASF policy before, in particular to the release and distribution policy. I guess you are asking for something

Re: Download source release / binary files in source release

2021-03-28 Thread Benedict Elliott Smith
Hi Justin, You are probably right, but as far as I am aware you are not an official source of ASF policy on this matter. The official policy pages do not stipulate this, so I would appreciate if you could get them updated to accord more clearly your beliefs before the project makes the necessar