Re: Which fix version should be used for the Quality Testing tickets

2020-12-09 Thread Mick Semb Wever
> I have thought that the fix version is the version which the item will be… fixed in… Others want the fix version to be the version which must not start until the ticket is closed… David, my understanding of it doesn't quite fit into this… Issues with a fixVersion of 4.0-beta indicate they are

Re: Which fix version should be used for the Quality Testing tickets

2020-12-09 Thread Joshua McKenzie
I read the release lifecycle a little differently when it comes to the quality tickets; I don't think it really speaks to those (areas without known defects but with known skepticism about their stability). If we find the text to be unclear or not address them we should definitely revise. Here's wh

Re: Which fix version should be used for the Quality Testing tickets

2020-12-09 Thread David Capwell
Thanks for bringing this up, this is a major form of confusion right now. I have thought that the fix version is the version which the item will be… fixed in… Others want the fix version to be the version which must not start until the ticket is closed… Both of these opinions are not documented an

Re: Which fix version should be used for the Quality Testing tickets

2020-12-09 Thread Michael Semb Wever
> Do we want them fixed before we release 4.0-RC or are they part of the > testing of the RC release? We are so unbearably close, it would be nice to see the beta tickets narrowed (again) to just the most critical issues. Tickets about creating new tests, and bugs edge-case, or not severe o

Which fix version should be used for the Quality Testing tickets

2020-12-09 Thread Benjamin Lerer
Hi everybody, Looking at the Dashboard, it seems that the *Quality Testing* tickets are spread between the Beta and RC releases. https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/RapidBoard.jspa?rapidView=355&quickFilter=1661 I assumed that those tickets were part of the Beta release but I might have misunde

Re: [DISCUSS] Bringing protocol v5 out of beta and dropping support from 3.11.x

2020-12-09 Thread Sam Tunnicliffe
> On 9 Dec 2020, at 02:41, Sumanth Pasupuleti > wrote: > > +1 to moving v5-beta changes in trunk to new protocol v6. > > Regarding 3.11 and v5, I suppose we could say, v5 could never get matured > beyond beta, but not sure if it would be confusing to see v6 while v5 is > still in beta (curio