If you are going to make 4 bigger as long as we call out that 3.11.x (or
whatever) will keep getting patches for stability only that's all that's
needed. We haven't gone to 3.x releases many places yet as we wait for a
release that will be stable longer. Knowing 4 is going to be bigger I
wouldn't w
>
> If they're not close to finished now why even consider them for the 4.0
> release?
Merging in major features at the end of a release cycle is not the path to
stability, imo.
On Mon, Apr 9, 2018 at 4:56 PM, Jonathan Haddad wrote:
> There's always more stuff to try to shoehorn in. We've done
There's always more stuff to try to shoehorn in. We've done big releases
with all the things, it never was stable. We tried the opposite end of the
spectrum, release every month, that really wasn't great either. Personally
I'd be OK with stopping new features by the end of this month and aiming
Myself I would put my non-binding vote for the stable side. I think those are
both important, but maybe they are best as some of the first things to go into
“release after 4.0”, not the last things to go into 4.0.
Maybe they would also prove as some incentive to get the next release out the
door
> I'd like to see pluggable storage and transient replica tickets land, for
> starters.
I think both those features are, frankly, necessary for our future. On
the other hand, they both have the following risks:
1. core behavioral changes
2. require changing a (relatively) large surface area of cod
I'd like to see pluggable storage and transient replica tickets land, for
starters.
On Mon, Apr 9, 2018 at 10:17 AM, Ben Bromhead wrote:
> >
> > For those wanting to delay, are we just dancing around inclusion of
> > some pet features? This is fine, I just think we need to communicate
> > what w
>
> For those wanting to delay, are we just dancing around inclusion of
> some pet features? This is fine, I just think we need to communicate
> what we are after if so.
>
+1 Some solid examples of tickets that won't make it with the proposed
timeline and a proposed alternative would help.
Otherw
Always interested in helping ! I submitted 2 small patches on 3.11 and trunk
Thank you
On 8 April 2018 at 01:34, Jay Zhuang wrote:
> Make senses to me. Not sure if I should just push a Ninja fix, created
> the ticket anyway: CASSANDRA-14370. Are you interested in creating a quick
> patch for i
