Re: Packaging Cassandra for Debian [was: Packaging Cassandra for Ubuntu]

2010-06-04 Thread Robert Edmonds
On 2010-06-05, Eric Evans wrote: > So Robert, I am DD as well, and so is Paul Cannon who chimed in earlier > in the discussion. As a Debian Developer and Cassandra user, would you > be interested in joining The Cause? :) sure, if you use git / git-buildpackage i'd be happy to join a cassandra pac

Re: Packaging Cassandra for Debian [was: Packaging Cassandra for Ubuntu]

2010-06-04 Thread Eric Evans
On Sat, 2010-06-05 at 01:38 +, Robert Edmonds wrote: > On 2010-06-04, Eric Evans wrote: > > So, the bigger problem here would seem to be one of long-term > support. > > In other words, trying to find common ground between release cycles. > > > > I am (have been) interested in uploading Cassand

Re: Packaging Cassandra for Debian [was: Packaging Cassandra for Ubuntu]

2010-06-04 Thread Robert Edmonds
On 2010-06-04, Eric Evans wrote: > So, the bigger problem here would seem to be one of long-term support. > In other words, trying to find common ground between release cycles. > > I am (have been) interested in uploading Cassandra to the Debian > archives, so let's use that as an example: as a d

Re: Packaging Cassandra for Debian [was: Packaging Cassandra for Ubuntu]

2010-06-04 Thread Jonathan Ellis
At the risk of repeating what everyone already knows, we (Eric) already have the "make a .deb with all the jars rolled into it" part done: http://wiki.apache.org/cassandra/DebianPackaging On Fri, Jun 4, 2010 at 12:41 PM, Torsten Curdt wrote: > It certainly would be nice to have it in the main Deb

Re: Packaging Cassandra for Debian

2010-06-04 Thread Eric Evans
On Fri, 2010-06-04 at 13:04 -0700, Clint Byrum wrote: > Right, this is precisely the reason we do make the effort to package > things when it makes sense. Projects that are fully matured and have > large user bases eventually stabilize. We may have jumped the gun a > bit by trying to get Cassandra

Re: Packaging Cassandra for Debian

2010-06-04 Thread Clint Byrum
On Jun 4, 2010, at 12:44 PM, Roland Dreier wrote: >> So, the bigger problem here would seem to be one of long-term support. >> In other words, trying to find common ground between release cycles. > > I really think the issue of versions and support cycles is not that big > a deal. There are lot

Re: Packaging Cassandra for Debian

2010-06-04 Thread Roland Dreier
> So, the bigger problem here would seem to be one of long-term support. > In other words, trying to find common ground between release cycles. I really think the issue of versions and support cycles is not that big a deal. There are lots of places that one could stick updated packages. The bi

Re: Packaging Cassandra for Debian [was: Packaging Cassandra for Ubuntu]

2010-06-04 Thread Torsten Curdt
It certainly would be nice to have it in the main Debian repo. On the other hand I don't think it's too much to ask to just add a line to the sources.list and have all the freedom of the world. I am personally not a huge fan of the Debian policy when it comes down to jars and java. It's just that s

Re: Packaging Cassandra for Debian [was: Packaging Cassandra for Ubuntu]

2010-06-04 Thread Peter Schuller
(To be clear: I'm not a cassandra developer, nor have I yet used Cassandra in a real production setting - though I'm hoping to...) > I'm curious what others think: My estimation is that Cassandra is not a "apt-get install and forget" type of software yet. If you're going to use cassandra, you are

Packaging Cassandra for Debian [was: Packaging Cassandra for Ubuntu]

2010-06-04 Thread Eric Evans
On Thu, 2010-06-03 at 07:55 -0700, Clint Byrum wrote: > So I am appealing to you, the Cassandra development community, to weigh in > with your recommendations on making Cassandra and its dependencies available > in Ubuntu. > > Specifically I'd like to address: > > * What is the perceived and re