Re: RAID 1 - software or hardware.

2011-12-22 Thread Camaleón
On Thu, 22 Dec 2011 11:00:10 +1000, yudi v wrote: >> I'd go for hardware RAID as long as there is a true and real hardware >> RAID controller behind with a battery backup et al (in brief, a *good* >> RAID controller, not the motherboard's one which are usually nothing >> but fakeraid and a pile of

Re: RAID 1 - software or hardware.

2011-12-21 Thread yudi v
> > Might be better to put LUKS on top of LVM instead of vice versa? Not sure. > > By having LVM over LUKS, I will only have one container to unlock and from what I understand Debian cannot unlock several LUKS containers at start-up unlike Fedora. My laptop currently has LVM over LUKS and works

Re: RAID 1 - software or hardware.

2011-12-21 Thread Kelly Clowers
On Wed, Dec 21, 2011 at 17:00, yudi v wrote: > >> I'd go for hardware RAID as long as there is a true and real hardware >> RAID controller behind with a battery backup et al (in brief, a *good* >> RAID controller, not the motherboard's one which are usually nothing but >> fakeraid and a pile of un

Re: RAID 1 - software or hardware.

2011-12-21 Thread yudi v
> I'd go for hardware RAID as long as there is a true and real hardware > RAID controller behind with a battery backup et al (in brief, a *good* > RAID controller, not the motherboard's one which are usually nothing but > fakeraid and a pile of unforeseen problems). > > Otherwise I would use softwa

Re: RAID 1 - software or hardware.

2011-12-21 Thread Bob Proulx
yudi v wrote: > > You would need a second compatible hardware raid controller to use > > in order to extract the data from the drives. The hardware raid > > controllers I have used have not allowed me to access the data > > without a compatible raid controller. > > If it's in RAID 1, I was under

Re: RAID 1 - software or hardware.

2011-12-21 Thread Camaleón
On Wed, 21 Dec 2011 16:11:32 +1000, yudi v wrote: > Will be installing a new system and would like to have the following > set-up: > > RAID 1 > LUKS > LVM > > Should I use the RAID controller on the motherboard (not sure how > reliable it will be) or use software RAID? I'd go for hardware RAID

Re: RAID 1 - software or hardware.

2011-12-21 Thread yudi v
> You would need > a second compatible hardware raid controller to use in order to > extract the data from the drives. The hardware raid controllers I > have used have not allowed me to access the data without a compatible > raid controller. If it's in RAID 1, I was under the impression that I w

Re: RAID 1 - software or hardware.

2011-12-20 Thread Bob Proulx
yudi v wrote: > Should I use the RAID controller on the motherboard (not sure how reliable > it will be) or use software RAID? The problem with the hardware raid on the motherboard is what do you do if the motherboard fails? You will at that time have good data on your disks but probably no way t

RAID 1 - software or hardware.

2011-12-20 Thread yudi v
Will be installing a new system and would like to have the following set-up: RAID 1 > LUKS > LVM Should I use the RAID controller on the motherboard (not sure how reliable it will be) or use software RAID? -- Kind regards, Yudi