Re: My first Linux crash

2002-11-04 Thread Shyamal Prasad
"Andrew" == Andrew Perrin <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: Andrew> FWIW, I'm skeptical of Nate's claim that excessive I/O Andrew> errors must bring down the system. I'm certainly not a Andrew> kernel hacker, but I see no reason why the kernel couldn't Andrew> do what it does in othe

Re: My first Linux crash

2002-11-04 Thread Chip Rose
On Monday 04 November 2002 09:59 am, Rob Weir wrote: > On Mon, Nov 04, 2002 at 08:58:07AM -0500, Andrew Perrin wrote: > > On Mon, 4 Nov 2002, Robert Ian Smit wrote: > > > I was surprised that this issue took down the system on Linux. > > > I understand, as nate explained, that hardware errors will

Re: My first Linux crash

2002-11-04 Thread Rob Weir
On Mon, Nov 04, 2002 at 08:58:07AM -0500, Andrew Perrin wrote: > On Mon, 4 Nov 2002, Robert Ian Smit wrote: > > > I was surprised that this issue took down the system on Linux. > > I understand, as nate explained, that hardware errors will always > > result in trouble but I expected the kernel to

Re: My first Linux crash

2002-11-04 Thread Christian Jaeger
At 14:50 Uhr +0100 04.11.2002, Robert Ian Smit wrote: I was surprised that this issue took down the system on Linux. I understand, as nate explained, that hardware errors will always result in trouble but I expected the kernel to react differently. (Or is this a limitation of x86 or the issue you

Re: My first Linux crash

2002-11-04 Thread Andrew Perrin
On Mon, 4 Nov 2002, Robert Ian Smit wrote: > I was surprised that this issue took down the system on Linux. > I understand, as nate explained, that hardware errors will always > result in trouble but I expected the kernel to react differently. > (Or is this a limitation of x86 or the issue you men

Re: My first Linux crash

2002-11-04 Thread Robert Ian Smit
* Ron Johnson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> [04-11-2002 13:28]: > > I was able to mount the cdrom and use tab-completion to get to the > > directory on the cdrom using cp. However after entering, the system > > crashed (leds on keyboard flashing, hard boot required). > What kind of mobo & chipset do you hav

Re: My first Linux crash

2002-11-04 Thread Ron Johnson
On Sun, 2002-11-03 at 21:09, Robert Ian Smit wrote: > Tonight I tried to copy the contents of a cdrom to a local > filesytem as root. > > I was able to mount the cdrom and use tab-completion to get to the > directory on the cdrom using cp. However after entering, the system > crashed (leds on keyb

Re: My first Linux crash

2002-11-03 Thread nate
Michael P. Soulier said: >Would not desirable behaviour be to log as many errors as possible, >but > recover from the hardware problem? I see no reason why any software, user > space or kernel space, should crash due to errors in a peripheral. Bad > RAM is one thing, but errors on a CD? I

Re: My first Linux crash

2002-11-03 Thread Michael P. Soulier
On 03/11/02 nate did speaketh: > it is not unusual, I have seen this happen on many operaitng systems > especially with CD-R media. the result would of been the same if > you were not root. Probably the system filled with I/O errors and > couldn't continue. The software has only limited resources

Re: My first Linux crash

2002-11-03 Thread nate
Robert Ian Smit said: > It's not really a very big issue, but I was amazed to see this > happen? it is not unusual, I have seen this happen on many operaitng systems especially with CD-R media. the result would of been the same if you were not root. Probably the system filled with I/O errors and

My first Linux crash

2002-11-03 Thread Robert Ian Smit
Tonight I tried to copy the contents of a cdrom to a local filesytem as root. I was able to mount the cdrom and use tab-completion to get to the directory on the cdrom using cp. However after entering, the system crashed (leds on keyboard flashing, hard boot required). After booting I took out th