Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-09 Thread Richard Lyons
On Sunday, 8 January 2006 at 21:13:17 -0500, Joey Hess wrote: > Angus Mackenzie wrote: > > The Tasksel stage of the installer could indeed make life easier for the > > neophyte. It could strongly advise them to install a desktop environment by > > default and make the choice of a console an opti

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-08 Thread Steve Lamb
Andy Streich wrote: > Steve, rather than defending the status quo perhaps you could bend a little > and hear the request being made in a different light. I'm not defending the status quo, I am pointing out the inaccuracies in what people are posting. I'm all for doing things better, believe

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-08 Thread Andy Streich
On Sunday 08 January 2006 10:30 am, Steve Lamb wrote: > Chris Howie wrote: > > And if that's the case then you select both of them during the install. > > On an advanced install that's exactly what you do. > > > Except that Debian put Gnome there when all I selected was "Desktop > > environment

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-08 Thread Joey Hess
Angus Mackenzie wrote: > The Tasksel stage of the installer could indeed make life easier for the > neophyte. It could strongly advise them to install a desktop environment by > default and make the choice of a console an option for those who Know What > They Are Doing, as I do 7 or 8 machines l

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-08 Thread Joris Huizer
Steve Lamb wrote: Joris Huizer wrote: I think, if the newbie just wants kde because of some fancy screenshots, it's too hard for him/her; remember the newbie doesn't know the character '/' upons up a search in so many linux/unix tools, so he/she is completely lost in an unknown interface Why wo

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-08 Thread Steve Lamb
Joris Huizer wrote: > I think, if the newbie just wants kde because of some fancy screenshots, > it's too hard for him/her; remember the newbie doesn't know the > character '/' upons up a search in so many linux/unix tools, so he/she > is completely lost in an unknown interface > Why would it compl

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-08 Thread Joris Huizer
Steve Lamb wrote: How hard can it be to give the user a choice during the install, and why is that such a stupid idea according to you? You are given a choice. You just refuse to see that. the way to choose is fine by me, but, for example, manually going through aptitude and finding

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-08 Thread Angus Mackenzie
I was that newbie 18 months ago! Debian was my first experience of Linux and I found ending up at a console after my first installation surprising and difficult. I got through it with lots of reading of documentation and googling, followed by a blundering and error prone crash course in apt-get

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-08 Thread Steve Lamb
Chris Howie wrote: > And if that's the case then you select both of them during the install. On an advanced install that's exactly what you do. > Except that Debian put Gnome there when all I selected was "Desktop > environment." Come on, you know that Linux users tend to value specificity.

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-07 Thread Gabriel Parrondo
Chris Howie wrote: Steve Lamb wrote: Or the system is going to have multiple users who might want different DEs. And if that's the case then you select both of them during the install. I still haven't uninstalled Gnome, something I've been meaning to do for a long time, but haven

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-07 Thread Chris Howie
Steve Lamb wrote: > Or the system is going to have multiple users who might want different DEs. And if that's the case then you select both of them during the install. >>I still haven't >>uninstalled Gnome, something I've been meaning to do for a long time, but >>haven't had the willpower to spen

Re: Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-06 Thread cmetzler
Don Jackson wrote: > John Hasler wrote: >> Don Jackson writes: >>> >>> I still don't know WHY there isn't a choice of desktops given the person >>> installing Debian. >> >> >> There is a choice of desktops. There is a choice of _everything_. > > OK, in the small context of the above quote, rev

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-06 Thread Steve Lamb
Chris Howie wrote: > Except now you're missing twice the disk space. Seriously, installing both > DEs > is a complete waste of space, unless the user is interested in evaluating both > DEs to see which one he likes better. Or the system is going to have multiple users who might want differen

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-06 Thread Chris Howie
Steve Lamb wrote: > Because (IIRC) the change is quite simple before the first login from the > GDM screen. I believe barring any user intervention to the contrary when a > GUI environment is selected *both* are installed and the user can choose his > poison from the GDM dropdown. Certainly d

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-06 Thread Steve Lamb
Don Jackson wrote: > Admittedly this is not a scientific poll, and I'm not interested in > starting (another) flame war over KDE vs. GNOME (send those comments to > /dev/null please), but I am interested in seeing the Debian Installer > give the user a choice during installation. Because (IIRC

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-06 Thread steef
Don Jackson wrote: This may be considered "off topic" by some, but I just stumbled on an interesting website with a program called "Linux Distribution Chooser". Even though I've been with Debian for a couple years now, I thought I'd just test out the "chooser"... http://www.zegeniestudios.net/l

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-06 Thread Anthony Campbell
On 06 Jan 2006, Don Jackson wrote: > This may be considered "off topic" by some, but I just stumbled on an > interesting website with a program called "Linux Distribution Chooser". > Even though I've been with Debian for a couple years now, I thought I'd > just test out the "chooser"... > > http:/

Re: Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-06 Thread Don Jackson
John Hasler wrote: > Don Jackson writes: > >>I still don't know WHY there isn't a choice of desktops given the person >>installing Debian. > > > There is a choice of desktops. There is a choice of _everything_. OK, in the small context of the above quote, revise that to say: "I still don't kno

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-06 Thread Craig M. Houck
D-kewl. I made honest selections regarding the last few builds with Debian I have done AND it selected Debian. I think of the Debian installer as at least a semi-GUI interface, but I guess it isn't! RbtBotL Craig - ><> oBU SysAdmin /|\ 607 777 6827 ^ Tot Ziens -- To UNSUBSCR

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-06 Thread John Hasler
Don Jackson writes: > I still don't know WHY there isn't a choice of desktops given the person > installing Debian. There is a choice of desktops. There is a choice of _everything_. -- John Hasler -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact

Re: Linux Distribution Chooser

2006-01-06 Thread Bruno Buys
Don Jackson escreveu: This may be considered "off topic" by some, but I just stumbled on an interesting website with a program called "Linux Distribution Chooser". Even though I've been with Debian for a couple years now, I thought I'd just test out the "chooser"... http://www.zegeniestudios.ne