Re: Bug#628042: perl: file creation in suid Perl script no longer works

2011-06-04 Thread Dominic Hargreaves
gt; this information or whether it should eventually go somewhere like the > > release notes for wheezy. > > My initial feeling is that this is overkill. The perl package is installed > on all Debian systems (well, 99.45% according to popcon), and I expect > that only a very ti

Re: suid-perl going away?

2007-08-23 Thread Marc Haber
On Thu, 23 Aug 2007 13:26:10 -0400, Joey Hess <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >Of course the downside is that only >people capable of writing secure C code need apply.. Yes. I am not one of these. Which is why I chose a script language. I find the idea of removing an existing and working tool quite di

Re: suid-perl going away?

2007-08-23 Thread Joey Hess
Marc Haber wrote: > What is the current recommended way to run perl scripts suid? Ever since that warning was added to perl-suid, many years ago, I've been writing my own suid wrappers for perl scripts in C. > Why is perl-suid going away, and how am I supposed to replace its > functionality? Wel

suid-perl going away?

2007-08-23 Thread Marc Haber
Hi, from the package description of perl-suid: | Usage of this program is now strongly deprecated upstream and support | (along with this package) will probably be removed in 5.10. What is the current recommended way to run perl scripts suid? Please note that I do not want to use sudo on the sys

Re: suid-perl

1999-01-31 Thread Chip Salzenberg
According to Jules Bean: > On Sun, 31 Jan 1999, Chip Salzenberg wrote: > > Consider that I may wish to mount a filesystem nosuid for the purpose > > of making a tape backup. Would I want the suid bits turned off in the > > backup image? I think not. > > Why not just mount it somewhere only you c

Re: suid-perl

1999-01-31 Thread Jules Bean
On Sun, 31 Jan 1999, Chip Salzenberg wrote: > According to Jules Bean: > > On Sun, 31 Jan 1999, Chip Salzenberg wrote: > > > Every OS has a different set of mount options that may or may not be > > > relevant to setuid security. I don't see what 'higher level' would be > > > useful. > > > > The

Re: suid-perl

1999-01-31 Thread Jules Bean
On Sun, 31 Jan 1999, Chip Salzenberg wrote: > > As it is, noexec is almost useless. I can't help thinking that > > *all* interpreters *should* check noexec status. > > What's the point? Such files can be copied to /tmp and run there If one were trying to secure such a system then you would

Re: suid-perl

1999-01-31 Thread Chip Salzenberg
According to Jules Bean: > On Sun, 31 Jan 1999, Chip Salzenberg wrote: > > Every OS has a different set of mount options that may or may not be > > relevant to setuid security. I don't see what 'higher level' would be > > useful. > > The correct solution to this, surely, is for the mount nosuid t

Re: suid-perl

1999-01-31 Thread Chip Salzenberg
According to Jules Bean: > On Sun, 31 Jan 1999, Chip Salzenberg wrote: > > The code exists to check the mount options relevant to an open file. > > It's just a Small Matter of Programming to integrate that into the > > Perl source code, and disable emultation of setuid scripts when the > > 'nosuid'

Re: suid-perl

1999-01-31 Thread Jules Bean
On Sun, 31 Jan 1999, Chip Salzenberg wrote: > > The code exists to check the mount options relevant to an open file. > It's just a Small Matter of Programming to integrate that into the > Perl source code, and disable emultation of setuid scripts when the > 'nosuid' mount option is set. But, then

Re: suid-perl

1999-01-31 Thread Chip Salzenberg
According to Michael Stone: > Quoting Chip Salzenberg ([EMAIL PROTECTED]): > > According to Michael Stone: > > > Quoting Wichert Akkerman ([EMAIL PROTECTED]): > > > > What perl-suid should do is check the mountoptions for the filesystem on > > > > which the script resides and abort if that was moun

Re: suid-perl

1999-01-31 Thread Jules Bean
On Sun, 31 Jan 1999, Chip Salzenberg wrote: > According to Michael Stone: > > Quoting Wichert Akkerman ([EMAIL PROTECTED]): > > > What perl-suid should do is check the mountoptions for the filesystem on > > > which the script resides and abort if that was mounted with nosuid. > > > Should be quite

Re: suid-perl

1999-01-31 Thread Michael Stone
Quoting Chip Salzenberg ([EMAIL PROTECTED]): > According to Michael Stone: > > Quoting Wichert Akkerman ([EMAIL PROTECTED]): > > > What perl-suid should do is check the mountoptions for the filesystem on > > > which the script resides and abort if that was mounted with nosuid. > > > Should be quite

Re: suid-perl

1999-01-31 Thread Chip Salzenberg
According to Michael Stone: > Quoting Wichert Akkerman ([EMAIL PROTECTED]): > > What perl-suid should do is check the mountoptions for the filesystem on > > which the script resides and abort if that was mounted with nosuid. > > Should be quite simple actually.. > > But that's still not general en