Re: [transcript] source package formats

2000-03-21 Thread Martin Bialasinski
* "Manoj" == Manoj Srivastava <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Manoj> One of the feature I like of a monolithic patch, as you call Manoj> it, is that when upstream incorporates changes previously made Manoj> by me or others, it is automatically handled on upgrade; the Manoj> monolithic patch just gets s

Re: [transcript] source package formats

2000-03-21 Thread Adam Heath
On 21 Mar 2000, Brian May wrote: > > "Adam" == Adam Heath <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > > How would you create these diffs? Please reread the mails. I said it only extracts. I've said nothing about building anything yet. > Also, have you considered how such a system could be integrated >

Re: [transcript] source package formats

2000-03-21 Thread Brian May
> "Adam" == Adam Heath <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: How would you create these diffs? Also, have you considered how such a system could be integrated with CVS? I guess cvs could be used to automatically generate the required diffs, given labels of key versions... Who would this work without

Re: [transcript] source package formats

2000-03-21 Thread Manoj Srivastava
>>"Adam" == Adam Heath <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: Adam> In the transcript, it is mentioned that I wrote dbs. It is a Adam> multi-tarball, multi-patch system, that is currently in use by Adam> several pkgs. However, it has its drawbacks, the 2 most Adam> glaring that it hides the source in s

Re: [transcript] source package formats

2000-03-21 Thread Adam Heath
On 21 Mar 2000, Brian May wrote: > I am not sure I like (or understand for that matter) the input tar.gz > files: > > 93c152103ca081bd993bb216952a61be 293809 xawtv_3.07.orig.tar.gz > 49d09b3edefb8279dc0ae1df3a42d15b 15908 xawtv_3.07-2.debian.tar.gz > fbb0a2fdc26934037ad11553f8f19814 2624 xawtv_

Re: [transcript] source package formats

2000-03-21 Thread Brian May
> "Adam" == Adam Heath <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: Adam> The script looks for all files matching the pattern Adam> *.diffs.tar.gz(yes, it allows multiple patch archives. This Adam> could be used to share between sources), then everything Adam> else that matches *.tar.gz is pla

Re: [transcript] source package formats

2000-03-21 Thread Joey Hess
Adam Heath wrote: > I say again. This is a .dsc unpacker, in the same way dpkg-source is. I really think you're going about this backwards, or at least sideways.. If you have an idea for a new source package format, write up a document explaining it in detail. Let people consider the implication

Re: [transcript] source package formats

2000-03-20 Thread Adam Heath
On Mon, 20 Mar 2000, Wichert Akkerman wrote: > Previously Adam Heath wrote: > > However, it has its drawbacks, the 2 most glaring that it hides the > > source in subtrees, all packed up, and that it doesn't extract into > > - directly. > > You conveniently ignored Ian's biggest con: it does not g

Re: [transcript] source package formats

2000-03-20 Thread Ben Collins
On Sun, Mar 19, 2000 at 11:55:27PM -0700, Jason Gunthorpe wrote: > > On Mon, 20 Mar 2000, Adam Heath wrote: > > > You'll note the addition of 3 fields(Format, Patches, and Tarballs), and the > > different files specified for the files field. The existance of a Format > > Having a .tarballs.tar.

Re: [transcript] source package formats

2000-03-20 Thread Wichert Akkerman
Previously Adam Heath wrote: > However, it has its drawbacks, the 2 most glaring that it hides the > source in subtrees, all packed up, and that it doesn't extract into > - directly. You conveniently ignored Ian's biggest con: it does not gave you a way to get to the source as it is compiles witho

Re: [transcript] source package formats

2000-03-20 Thread Hamish Moffatt
On Mon, Mar 20, 2000 at 01:51:08AM -0600, Adam Heath wrote: > Comments? Suggestions? You still owe me documentation for this :-) bug#52351 on xawtv. Cheers Hamish -- Hamish Moffatt VK3SB <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

Re: [transcript] source package formats

2000-03-20 Thread Adam Heath
On Sun, 19 Mar 2000, Jason Gunthorpe wrote: > > On Mon, 20 Mar 2000, Adam Heath wrote: > > > You'll note the addition of 3 fields(Format, Patches, and Tarballs), and the > > different files specified for the files field. The existance of a Format > > Having a .tarballs.tar.gz seems rather poin

Re: [transcript] source package formats

2000-03-20 Thread Jason Gunthorpe
On Mon, 20 Mar 2000, Adam Heath wrote: > You'll note the addition of 3 fields(Format, Patches, and Tarballs), and the > different files specified for the files field. The existance of a Format Having a .tarballs.tar.gz seems rather pointless, just have all the tars seperate - as does including

Re: [transcript] source package formats

2000-03-20 Thread Adam Heath
On Sun, 19 Mar 2000, Joey Hess wrote: > [ This is a transcript of a conversation on the Debian developer irc > channel. Note that Diziet is Ian Jackson. This transcript has been edited > for clarity and to remove other simulantaneous conversations. ] Thanks Joey for posting that. Ok, now for