Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-15 Thread Remco Blaakmeer
On Mon, 15 Jun 1998, Santiago Vila wrote: > -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- > > On 14 Jun 1998, Guy Maor wrote: > > > passwd is required and that is enough. You can assume that all > > required packages are always on the system. > > I disagree. Since you are able to remove a required-but-no

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-15 Thread Santiago Vila
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- On 14 Jun 1998, Guy Maor wrote: > passwd is required and that is enough. You can assume that all > required packages are always on the system. I disagree. Since you are able to remove a required-but-non-essential package and dpkg does not complain, required-bu

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-14 Thread Guy Maor
James Troup <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > My original objection was going to be base around the fact that passwd > is Essential, but it turns out it isn't, my bad. I'd hate to be part > of the current `Let's make foo Essential: yes and part of the base > system, in fact let's make it the kernel'

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-10 Thread Martin Schulze
On Wed, Jun 10, 1998 at 07:49:48AM +0200, Scott Hanson wrote: > > > The problem is that the _preinst_ might use the programs useradd and > > > groupadd. These are not in the base system nor essential. They're > > > included in the passwd package. They might use configuration files > > > that mi

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-10 Thread Scott Hanson
Martin Schulze <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > On Mon, Jun 08, 1998 at 12:55:53PM +0200, Martin Schulze wrote: ---snip--- > > The problem is that the _preinst_ might use the programs useradd and > > groupadd. These are not in the base system nor essential. They're > > included in the passwd packa

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-09 Thread Martin Schulze
On Mon, Jun 08, 1998 at 12:55:53PM +0200, Martin Schulze wrote: > I have moved msql 2.0.3-4 into Incoming/REJECT > > - Forwarded message from James Troup <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> - > > [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Martin Schulze) writes: > > >* Added pre-dependency for passwd to msqld as its tools

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-08 Thread Martin Schulze
On Mon, Jun 08, 1998 at 02:26:09PM +0200, Richard Braakman wrote: > Martin Schulze wrote: > > The problem is that the _preinst_ might use the programs useradd and > > groupadd. > > Why not do it in the postinst, at configure time? Then a normal > dependency is enough. Because the uid should be p

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-08 Thread Richard Braakman
Martin Schulze wrote: > The problem is that the _preinst_ might use the programs useradd and > groupadd. Why not do it in the postinst, at configure time? Then a normal dependency is enough. If the user or group does not exist on the system, dpkg will use the numeric IDs instead. Richard Braakm

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-08 Thread Martin Schulze
On Mon, Jun 08, 1998 at 12:17:52PM +0100, James Troup wrote: > Martin Schulze <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > > > >* Added pre-dependency for passwd to msqld as its tools are used > > > in the preinst. > > > > Does anybody object? > > My original objection was going to be base around the f

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-08 Thread James Troup
Martin Schulze <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > >* Added pre-dependency for passwd to msqld as its tools are used > > in the preinst. > > Does anybody object? My original objection was going to be base around the fact that passwd is Essential, but it turns out it isn't, my bad. I'd hate to

Re: RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-08 Thread Santiago Vila
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- On Mon, 8 Jun 1998, Martin Schulze wrote: > [...] > Does anybody object? > > The problem is that the _preinst_ might use the programs useradd and > groupadd. These are not in the base system nor essential. They're > included in the passwd package. They might

RETRACTED msql 2.0.3-4

1998-06-08 Thread Martin Schulze
I have moved msql 2.0.3-4 into Incoming/REJECT - Forwarded message from James Troup <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> - [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Martin Schulze) writes: >* Added pre-dependency for passwd to msqld as its tools are used > in the preinst. You're meant to obtain a consensus on debian-