Bug#873211: lintian: does not warn about .class binaries

2017-09-25 Thread Chris Lamb
Hi Emmanuel! > Thanks for improving the Java support in Lintian, I'd suggest CCing > these topics to debian-j...@lists.debian.org to gather more feedback on > the proposed changes. Sure! Indeed, once you think you have reached a consensus could you file new and separte, wishlist bugs against Lin

Bug#873211: lintian: does not warn about .class binaries

2017-09-25 Thread Markus Koschany
Hi, A big +1 for everything what Emmanuel stated above with a special emphasis on the following points: * Thanks for improving Lintian! * Please keep us in the loop about Java related Lintian changes. Perhaps we are not always able to provide code in a timely manner but we are willing to prov

Bug#873211: lintian: does not warn about .class binaries

2017-09-25 Thread Emmanuel Bourg
On Wed, 20 Sep 2017 17:34:47 + Chris Lamb wrote: > lintian (2.5.53) unstable; urgency=medium > . >* Summary of tag changes: > + Added: >- package-installs-java-bytecode Hi, Thanks for improving the Java support in Lintian, I'd suggest CCing these topics to debian-j...@list

Bug#873211: lintian: does not warn about .class binaries

2017-08-25 Thread Chris Lamb
severity 873211 wishlist retitle 873211 Please warn about binary packages shipping .class files thanks Hi Carnë, > The problem I'm reporting is c), the files are not recompiled. Okay, so this can also be the case with .jar too (!) but let's leave that for another day/bug. :) > Also, sicne you m

Bug#873211: lintian: does not warn about .class binaries

2017-08-25 Thread Carnë Draug
On 25 August 2017 at 16:20, Chris Lamb wrote: > Hi Carnë, > >> While improving the packaging of a Debian package, I found that the >> source release included .class files > > I guess we should be explicit about the problem we are trying to > solve here; ie. which of: > > a) That upstream ships .cl

Bug#873211: lintian: does not warn about .class binaries

2017-08-25 Thread Chris Lamb
Hi Carnë, > While improving the packaging of a Debian package, I found that the > source release included .class files I guess we should be explicit about the problem we are trying to solve here; ie. which of: a) That upstream ships .class files to begin with (which I worry and suspect might be

Bug#873211: lintian: does not warn about .class binaries

2017-08-25 Thread Carnë Draug
Package: lintian Version: 2.5.50.4 Severity: normal Dear Maintainer, While improving the packaging of a Debian package, I found that the source release included .class files (pre compiled java files). Those .class files were also part of the upstream release. These upstream compiled files were