Bug#520668: TCP SYN cookies

2010-02-17 Thread Craig Small
Hello, Regarding the procps bug 520668 which was asking for the TCP SYN cookies to be enabled by default, I've looked at the various emails to and for. While it does seem like it would be a good idea at times, there is not a consensus that it is a good *default* Nothing about this bug would cha

Bug#520668: TCP SYN cookies and Bug #520668

2010-02-13 Thread Peter Palfrader
On Sat, 13 Feb 2010, Florian Weimer wrote: > * Craig Small: > > > While initially skeptical, I can see that under high TCP loads having > > some sort of connection is better than having no connection. Connections > > with large windows will be dropped, but they would be anyhow. > > This argument

Bug#520668: TCP SYN cookies and Bug #520668

2010-02-13 Thread Florian Weimer
* Craig Small: > While initially skeptical, I can see that under high TCP loads having > some sort of connection is better than having no connection. Connections > with large windows will be dropped, but they would be anyhow. This argument ignores the non-attack overload case. Lack of window sca

Bug#520668: TCP SYN cookies and Bug #520668

2010-02-13 Thread Ben Hutchings
On Sat, 2010-02-13 at 16:08 +0100, Bastian Blank wrote: > On Sun, Feb 14, 2010 at 12:42:09AM +1100, Craig Small wrote: > > Before I make this change, I am emailling debian-devel for comments. I > > am looking in particular for information about why it could be harmful > > (if it is). > > You forgo

Bug#520668: TCP SYN cookies and Bug #520668

2010-02-13 Thread Julien Cristau
On Sun, Feb 14, 2010 at 00:42:09 +1100, Craig Small wrote: > My proposal is to change sysctl.conf so by default it will have TCP SYN > cookies ENABLED. Anyone is quite able to change this but the default is > proposed to be enabled. > > Before I make this change, I am emailling debian-devel for

Bug#520668: TCP SYN cookies and Bug #520668

2010-02-13 Thread Bastian Blank
On Sun, Feb 14, 2010 at 12:42:09AM +1100, Craig Small wrote: > Before I make this change, I am emailling debian-devel for comments. I > am looking in particular for information about why it could be harmful > (if it is). You forgot to mail the maintainer of the package you change the configuration

Bug#520668: TCP SYN cookies and Bug #520668

2010-02-13 Thread Craig Small
Hello, There has been a bug opened for a while to enable TCP SYN cookies by default. The current situation is /etc/sysctl.conf has this option, but it is commented out. The procps (sysctl.conf) bug is http://bugs.debian.org/520668 you may also like to read the discussion about tcp(7) man page at