Bug#1103719: dhcpcd configured DNS server disappears when using systemd-resolved

2025-04-26 Thread Ken Milmore
The issue I raised upstream has now been closed [1], after Roy produced a new release of openresolv [2] with support for systemd-resolved. Unfortunately, IMHO the direction taken in openresolv doesn't help us much with the present bug, for the following reasons: - It violates the principle of

Bug#1103719: dhcpcd configured DNS server disappears when using systemd-resolved

2025-04-21 Thread Daniel Gröber
Hi Ken, Thanks for raising this, I've had a hunch things are still a bit dodgy in this area for a while now. I'm overall not very happy with Debian's DNS configuration story and I've been meaning to have a go at improving the situation, but so far I haven't been able to focus on it. If you want

Bug#1103719: dhcpcd configured DNS server disappears when using systemd-resolved

2025-04-21 Thread Ken Milmore
Further to our upstream discussion at [1] I have raised wishlist Bug#1103785 [2] for systemd-resolved. With trixie release coming up, I would not expect to see any enthusiasm for making these sorts of changes across multiple packages. For now I guess you have the option of patching the hook scr

Bug#1103719: dhcpcd configured DNS server disappears when using systemd-resolved

2025-04-21 Thread Ken Milmore
On 21/04/2025 06:04, Martin-Éric Racine wrote: > Hey Ken, > > > Thanks for this bug report and very thorough analysis. > > Can you submit a report upstream and link to this bug? > > https://github.com/NetworkConfiguration/dhcpcd/issues/new > > Martin-Éric I have done so: https://github.com/Ne

Bug#1103719: dhcpcd configured DNS server disappears when using systemd-resolved

2025-04-20 Thread Martin-Éric Racine
Hey Ken, ma 21.4.2025 klo 1.42 Ken Milmore (ken.milm...@gmail.com) kirjoitti: > > Package: dhcpcd-base > Version: 1:10.1.0-9 > > Description: > > When using dhcpcd-base together with systemd-resolved, the name server > settings for an interface are initially configured correctly from DHCP but >

Bug#1103719: dhcpcd configured DNS server disappears when using systemd-resolved

2025-04-20 Thread Ken Milmore
Package: dhcpcd-base Version: 1:10.1.0-9 Description: When using dhcpcd-base together with systemd-resolved, the name server settings for an interface are initially configured correctly from DHCP but may then subsequently disappear, leaving no DNS server configured. This is because the dhcpcd