Re: adding bootstrap and bootstrap.conf

2007-03-23 Thread Bruno Haible
Eric Blake wrote: > > Find attached a patch that implements the first part of it. The > > second part will be the handling of CLEANFILES and MOSTLYCLEANFILES. > > No attachment, but I see you applied the patch? Indeed, the attachment got lost when I had to resend the mail, due to earlier mail pro

Re: adding bootstrap and bootstrap.conf

2007-03-23 Thread Eric Blake
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 According to Bruno Haible on 3/19/2007 6:19 PM: > Jim Meyering wrote: >> Another feature: bootstrap adds .cvsignore and .gitignore >> entries for files it supplies. > > Good idea. It has annoyed me as well, but never reached the necessary pain > level

Re: adding bootstrap and bootstrap.conf

2007-03-19 Thread Bruno Haible
Jim Meyering wrote: > Another feature: bootstrap adds .cvsignore and .gitignore > entries for files it supplies. Good idea. It has annoyed me as well, but never reached the necessary pain level. Find attached a patch that implements the first part of it. The second part will be the handling of CLE

Re: adding bootstrap and bootstrap.conf

2007-03-19 Thread Bruno Haible
Jim Meyring wrote: > My impression is that few (if any) of the autogen scripts use gnulib The one in gettext does. > there's another definition (the first one when I type "dict bootstrap") > that is more evocative: to load and initialize the operating system on > a computer. Normally abbreviated

Re: adding bootstrap and bootstrap.conf

2007-03-19 Thread Paul Eggert
Bruno Haible <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > Can you try to solve both problems through overrides in > coreutils/gl/modules/gettext.diff and coreutils/gl/m4/* ? > If you get that working, I can see what needs to be changed in gnulib's > gettext module. In the current state, I don't even have a preci

Re: adding bootstrap and bootstrap.conf

2007-03-18 Thread Karl Berry
configure, make, etc. operations should be remove by "make maintainer-clean". It occurs to me that perhaps it is desirable to split maintainer-clean (keep it as it is) and (say) bootstrap-clean after all. I can imagine, as a maintainer, wanting to rm everything *except* the bootstrap stuff -

Re: adding bootstrap and bootstrap.conf

2007-03-18 Thread Jim Meyering
[EMAIL PROTECTED] (Karl Berry) wrote: > The only reason maintainer-clean typically has not removed files like > configure and Makefile.am is that they have been (until relatively > recently) version controlled. > > That doesn't seem quite right to me. Makefile.am is typically Whoops.

Re: adding bootstrap and bootstrap.conf

2007-03-18 Thread Karl Berry
The only reason maintainer-clean typically has not removed files like configure and Makefile.am is that they have been (until relatively recently) version controlled. That doesn't seem quite right to me. Makefile.am is typically version-controlled and always has been; furthermore, con

Re: adding bootstrap and bootstrap.conf

2007-03-18 Thread Jim Meyering
Bruno Haible <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Jim Meyering wrote: ... >> A missing feature: files supplied by gnulib-tool should be >> removed by "make maintainer-clean". If gnulib-tool doesn't >> do that soon, I'll be changing bootstrap to do it. > > It belongs in gnulib-tool, so please change gnulib

Re: adding bootstrap and bootstrap.conf

2007-03-17 Thread Bruce Korb
Ben Pfaff wrote: > Bruno Haible <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > >> GNOME and some other GNU projects use the name 'autogen.sh' for scripts with >> this purpose. It's a well-known and self-explaining name. I'd suggest to >> rename 'bootstrap' to 'autogen.sh'. > > One oddity of the name "autogen.sh"

Re: adding bootstrap and bootstrap.conf

2007-03-17 Thread Ben Pfaff
Bruno Haible <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > GNOME and some other GNU projects use the name 'autogen.sh' for scripts with > this purpose. It's a well-known and self-explaining name. I'd suggest to > rename 'bootstrap' to 'autogen.sh'. One oddity of the name "autogen.sh" is that there is a GNU proje

Re: adding bootstrap and bootstrap.conf

2007-03-17 Thread Jim Meyering
Bruno Haible <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Jim Meyring wrote: >> My impression is that few (if any) of the autogen scripts use gnulib > > The one gettext does. > >> there's another definition (the first one when I type "dict bootstrap") >> that is more evocative: to load and initialize the operatin

Re: adding bootstrap and bootstrap.conf

2007-03-16 Thread Paul Eggert
Jim Meyering <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: >> Second, the script applies gnulib-tool on a scratch subdirectory. This is >> worrisome: it indicates that gnulib-tool does some things the wrong way. >> Can you or Paul explain what is missing in gnulib-tool's working? > > I wouldn't say it's wrong, just

Re: adding bootstrap and bootstrap.conf

2007-03-16 Thread Jim Meyering
Bruno Haible <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> Variants of this bootstrap script are being used in at least 6 or >> 7 different projects, and having it here seems like the best way >> to keep everyone up to date. However there's plenty of room for >> improvement. > > Well, I'd suggest two improvements

Re: adding bootstrap and bootstrap.conf

2007-03-12 Thread Bruno Haible
Hello Jim, > Variants of this bootstrap script are being used in at least 6 or > 7 different projects, and having it here seems like the best way > to keep everyone up to date. However there's plenty of room for > improvement. Well, I'd suggest two improvements: First, the name. "Bootstrapping"