Re: willing to contribute verrevcmp to gnulib?

2008-09-30 Thread Ian Jackson
Ian Jackson writes ("Re: willing to contribute verrevcmp to gnulib?"): > Did you base your version on the Debian specification at > http://www.debian.org/doc/debian-policy/ch-controlfields.html#s-f-Version > ? And another thing: you should put a comment in it saying /* *

Re: willing to contribute verrevcmp to gnulib?

2008-09-30 Thread Ian Jackson
Kamil Dudka writes ("Re: willing to contribute verrevcmp to gnulib?"): > we use the extended version (handling ~ character), even slightly > modified to work better with file names (with suffixes). The new > (gnulib) filevercmp code is in attachment. Sorry, I overlooked this message before. Now I

Re: willing to contribute verrevcmp to gnulib?

2008-09-30 Thread Ian Jackson
AJ: the FSF want to put an implementation of the dpkg version comparison algorithm into gnulib. I approve of this, but the git logs say that the current version was supplied by you. There are some copyright questions. Jim Meyering writes ("Re: willing to contribute verrevcmp to gnulib?"): > Brun

Re: willing to contribute verrevcmp to gnulib?

2008-09-29 Thread Ian Jackson
Also, ... > > > Is there a chance that you would be willing to contribute to the > > > FSF the actual code from dpkg for this? (Otherwise, we will > > > probably have one person write a formal specification for the > > > version comparison algorithm, and then another person implement > > > somethi

Re: willing to contribute verrevcmp to gnulib?

2008-09-29 Thread Ian Jackson
Jim Meyering writes ("Re: willing to contribute verrevcmp to gnulib?"): > Depending on the code: GPL, LGPL, LGPLv2+. > For this function, LGPL or LGPLv2+ would be appropriate, > since it's intended to replace glibc's strverscmp. Right. I hereby permit, insofar as I am able, the relicensing of dpk

Re: willing to contribute verrevcmp to gnulib?

2008-09-29 Thread Ian Jackson
Ian Jackson writes ("Re: willing to contribute verrevcmp to gnulib?"): > What precisely is the problem ? Is it just that the version in dpkg > is GPLv2+ and you want something more liberal ? And which files are we talking about ? NB that the dpkg comparison algorithm was rece

Re: willing to contribute verrevcmp to gnulib?

2008-09-29 Thread Ian Jackson
Ian Jackson writes ("Re: willing to contribute verrevcmp to gnulib?"): > What is the licence on gnulib ? I'm very probably be happy to > relicence. I see that there is a mixture of licenses in gnulib. What precisely is the problem ? Is it just that the version in dpkg i

Re: willing to contribute verrevcmp to gnulib?

2008-09-29 Thread Ian Jackson
Jim Meyering writes ("Re: willing to contribute verrevcmp to gnulib?"): > Ben Pfaff <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Hi Ian. The GNU gnulib project is considering adding a function > > that would compare strings in the same way that dpkg compares > > version numbers, as you can see in the thread her