Re: auto-inserting COPYING

2008-12-13 Thread Karl Berry
I think it would make Automake less convenient, which is why I chose against it, but that's of course only my opinion. I think the potential for confusion outweighs by far the trivial convenience, but that's of course only my opinion too. And yes, the only other sane semantics IMVHO w

Re: auto-inserting COPYING

2008-12-13 Thread Ralf Wildenhues
Hello Karl, * Karl Berry wrote on Sat, Dec 13, 2008 at 01:14:54AM CET: > according to NEWS it was actually deprecated in version 1.8. > > So maybe it's time to remove it, instead of adding the warning (as Ralf > so recently did)? Yes, the warning was added very recently, in 1.10.2 only, as a

Re: auto-inserting COPYING

2008-12-12 Thread Karl Berry
according to NEWS it was actually deprecated in version 1.8. So maybe it's time to remove it, instead of adding the warning (as Ralf so recently did)? In this case, it seems to me the resulting incompatibility (of not adding the file) is actually desirable because it will force the autho

Re: auto-inserting COPYING

2008-12-11 Thread Ralf Wildenhues
Hi Karl, Peter, * Peter Johansson wrote on Fri, Dec 12, 2008 at 03:24:18AM CET: > Karl Berry wrote: >> I just learned that in some circumstances automake will insert a COPYING >> file if it's missing (albeit with a warning), e.g., at make dist? (I >> didn't look into the precise details.) Never

Re: auto-inserting COPYING

2008-12-11 Thread Peter Johansson
Hi Karl, Karl Berry wrote: I just learned that in some circumstances automake will insert a COPYING file if it's missing (albeit with a warning), e.g., at make dist? (I didn't look into the precise details.) This is a very old feature and according to NEWS it was actually deprecated in vers

auto-inserting COPYING

2008-12-11 Thread Karl Berry
I just learned that in some circumstances automake will insert a COPYING file if it's missing (albeit with a warning), e.g., at make dist? (I didn't look into the precise details.) I expect there's probably been plenty of discussion about it that I'm unaware of, but to my naive eyes, this is simp