Shadow data member

2021-09-29 Thread Nick Savoiu via Gcc 
Should GCC report shadowing on 'valid' for this code?
Nick

struct S1{bool valid;};
struct S2 : public S1{bool valid;};
struct S3 : public S2{bool valid;};

Re: Shadow data member

2021-09-29 Thread Nick Savoiu via Gcc 
Ok, sorry. I'll ask it on gcc-help.
Nick
 
 
  On Wed, Sep 29, 2021 at 1:35 PM, Jonathan Wakely 
wrote:   On Wed, 29 Sept 2021 at 21:34, Nick Savoiu via Gcc  
wrote:
>
> Should GCC report shadowing on 'valid' for this code?
> Nick
>
> struct S1{    bool valid;};
> struct S2 : public S1{    bool valid;};
> struct S3 : public S2{    bool valid;};

This question belongs on the gcc-help list, not here.

IMHO, this is name hiding, now shadowing.