RE: Different binding addresses for traffic & membership

2021-01-22 Thread Alberto Bustamante Reyes
Thanks for your answer Dan! We have checked that setting "0.0.0.0" in DirectChannel and in GMSHealthMonitor seems to solve our problem. I created PR to check if using "0.0.0.0" could have an impact and all public test cases seems to work fine in that case (https://github.com/apache/geode/pull/59

[DISCUSS] RFC - Add option to allow newer Geode clients to connect to older Geode servers

2021-01-22 Thread Alberto Gomez
Hi Geode devs, I have just published the following RFC in the Geode wiki: "Add option to allow newer Geode clients to connect to older Geode servers" https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/GEODE/Add+option+to+allow+newer+Geode+clients+to+connect+to+older+Geode+servers Could you please prov

Re: [DISCUSS] RFC - Add option to allow newer Geode clients to connect to older Geode servers

2021-01-22 Thread Patrick Johnson
It sounds like you intend to test which versions are compatible with each other and maintain a list the client can use to reject the setting of force-version when set to an incompatible version. If that’s the case, why not just have the handshake look at that list and automatically connect with

Re: [DISCUSS] RFC - Add option to allow newer Geode clients to connect to older Geode servers

2021-01-22 Thread Alberto Gomez
Thanks for your comments, Patrick. Do you mean have the client always use in the handshake the oldest server version it is compatible with? Sounds like a reasonable simplification. In that case, I would use a flag to activate this behavior so that the current behavior (the client sends the cur