I took Hal Burgiss's firewall script (modified version of nerdherd)
and it seems to work as advertised for me.

I test it with ShieldsUP   http://grc.com/x/ne.dll?rh1ck2l2
(or  https://grc.com/x/ne.dll?bh0bkyd2 ...not sure ofthe exactaddr)

and many ports previously shown as
'open' now show as 'stealth'

I left ftp(21) open, and identd(113) open

are either necessary?

-- if i want to ftp to my firewall box at home from
somewhere else, say at work,
  for downloading a file on homebox to the workcomputer
or for uploading a workfile to my homebox
do I or don't I need ftp open on my home firewallbox?

--I am even less knowledgeable about identd(113) . I think Hal left
  thisone open....
Are there clear guidelines as to when it is advisable to leave
identd open?


FYI and a plug for ShieldsUP: it is trivial to use.
it probes your ports and returns one of
open ---generally bad
closed ---good but port still visible...
stealth --- best for security

here is the partial response to its probing of my system
_before_ implementing the firewall

21 ftp open
25  smtp open
80 http open
113 ident open
139 netbios open

23 telnet closed
79 finger closed
110 pop3 closed
143 imap closed
443 htps closed

and here is the response
----with new firewall.sh  in /usr/sbin
--- and called as last command  from  /etc/rc.d/rc.local

21 ftp open  FTP servers have many known security vulnerabilities ...

23 telnet stealth     There is NO EVIDENCE WHATSOEVER that a port
                  (or even any computer) exists at this IP address!...

25 smtp stealth
79 finger stealth
80 http stealth
110 pop3 stealth

113 ident open  Identification/Authorization Service - Internet servers such 
as POP, IMAP, SMTP, and IRC query this port in response to client 
connections.It should NEVER be open since this is a source of tremendous 
information escape.

139 netbios stealth
143 imap stealth
443 https stealth
------ end of response from shieldsup

so everything is stealth, except for  ftp(21) and identd(113)
which ShieldsUP says should be at least _closed_  if not _stealth_.

I dont think I have a clue as to how to get identd to _closed_.
I think if i take out the explicit opening in the firewall it
will show up as _stealth_ like the others shown above.

regards,
Jack

________________________________________________________________________
Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com


-- 
To unsubscribe: mail [EMAIL PROTECTED] with "unsubscribe"
as the Subject.

Reply via email to