On Thursday, June 12, 2025 at 10:29:06 AM UTC+2 Andreas Heigl wrote:

Hey folks. 

Ben Ramsey proposed an idea on Mastodon[1] to create a registry that 
holds and provides user-space attributes for PHP. 

His idea was to start a PSR that defines the registry and the processes 
to add, modify and remove attributes from that registry. 

Having something like such a registry provided by FIG would allow a much 
easier adoption in the PHP-community and by tools than either creating 
such a registry by someone else privately (why should they be trusted) 
or by one of the bigger framework-projects or company. 


This sounds like something that fits well within our mission of 
interoperability, so I see that this is something that the FIG should 
facilitate. 

I think the registry should have more of an informational character (yellow 
pages), than an authoritative one. When certain registrations point to 
common interest, it could trigger standardizing them in a PSR.

To maintain the registry though is probably not something the current 
FIG processes are fit, so defining a separate process to maintain such a 
registry would be a part of the PSR to define. 


What are your thoughts on that? 


We should explore the options. While we could define the registry and its 
processes trough the PSR or PER processes, I can also imagine that we 
create a more tailor-made process with a bylaw change.
 

I would definitely be willing to form or join a Working Group. As would 
Jaap van Otterdijk (PHP-Documentor) and Juliet Reinders-Follmer 
(PHP-Codesniffer) 


I'd like to join this Working Group. If needed, I'm also willing to be the 
CC Sponsor.

--
Regards,
Vincent de Lau

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "PHP 
Framework Interoperability Group" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To view this discussion visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/php-fig/bc23bd86-ad97-4661-aad0-ff9440fbb7edn%40googlegroups.com.
              • ... 'Andreas Heigl' via PHP Framework Interoperability Group
              • ... Larry Garfield
              • ... 'Andreas Heigl' via PHP Framework Interoperability Group
              • ... Korvin Szanto
              • ... 'Andreas Heigl' via PHP Framework Interoperability Group
              • ... Korvin Szanto
              • ... 'Andreas Heigl' via PHP Framework Interoperability Group
              • ... Larry Garfield
              • ... 'Andreas Heigl' via PHP Framework Interoperability Group
        • Re: ... Eric Fortmeyer
  • Re: Creating a Re... Vincent de Lau
  • Re: Creating a Re... Larry Garfield

Reply via email to