ID: 26469 Comment by: brion at pobox dot com Reported By: f23wop602 at sneakemail dot com Status: Bogus Bug Type: Reproducible crash Operating System: RH7 2.2.16-22 PHP Version: 4.3.4 New Comment:
The given script works for me without crashing on 4.3.2 (Linux/x86, Red Hat 7.3 and Red Hat 9.0, and MacOS X 10.3.1). The original poster has told me that it works for him in 4.3.4 beta and crashes only in 4.3.4 release. Anyway, it's okay for the regexp to _fail_ if you're pushing the limits, but returning an error code would be nicer that smashing the stack and segfaulting. In web applications with possibly untrusted data this can be a security risk, and that's PHP's primary use. Might there be a way to get PCRE to handle such conditions gracefully? Previous Comments: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2003-11-30 04:12:54] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Not PHP bug. You just run into the documented PCRE limitations.. check http://www.pcre.org/pcre.txt for topic "LIMITATIONS". ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2003-11-29 20:13:24] f23wop602 at sneakemail dot com Description: ------------ We had some crashes, and after some tracking we found a regexp which crashes on specific data. The data is contained in the script in the URL below, I cut it down as much as I could while still triggering the crash. Reproduce code: --------------- http://test.wikipedia.org/crash-php4.3.4.txt Most of it is just data, the crash occurs on the regexp on the data at the end. Actual result: -------------- (gdb) bt #0 0x808225c in match ( eptr=0x81b4ec0 "kuterat: Enligt ''Miller'' (53) kommer en Psi-liknande form (Ψ) av kappa från Proto-Kanaaneiska. Kappa stod troligtvis för /k/ såväl som /k_h/ i tidig grekisk ortografi och senare återinfördes den"..., ecode=0x81b5e56 "8˙˙˙˙\177˙˙˙˙˙˙ī", '˙' <repeats 20 times>, "=", offset_top=4, md=0xbfffca50, ims=0, eptrb=0xbf800198, flags=2) at /tmp/php-4.3.4/ext/pcre/pcrelib/pcre.c:4986 #1 0x808236e in match ( eptr=0x81b4ec0 "kuterat: Enligt ''Miller'' (53) kommer en Psi-liknande form (Ψ) av kappa från Proto-Kanaaneiska. Kappa stod troligtvis för /k/ såväl som /k_h/ i tidig grekisk ortografi och senare återinfördes den"..., ecode=0x81b5e53 "M", offset_top=4, md=0xbfffca50, ims=0, eptrb=0xbf800198, flags=2) at /tmp/php-4.3.4/ext/pcre/pcrelib/pcre.c:5059 #2 0x8082eb0 in match ( eptr=0x81b4ec0 "kuterat: Enligt ''Miller'' (53) kommer en Psi-liknande form (Ψ) av kappa från Proto-Kanaaneiska. Kappa stod troligtvis för /k/ såväl som /k_h/ i tidig grekisk ortografi och senare återinfördes den"..., ecode=0x81b5e7e "?", offset_top=4, md=0xbfffca50, ims=0, eptrb=0xbf800678, flags=2) at /tmp/php-4.3.4/ext/pcre/pcrelib/pcre.c:5583 [snip] #11143 0x808236e in match ( eptr=0x81b38fd ">\r\n\t<td>[[Rho]]</td>\r\n\t<td>[rO:]</td>\r\n\t<td>[ro]</td>\r\n\t<td> </td>\r\n\t<td>[r]</td>\r\n\t<td>[r]</td>\r\n\t<td>100</td>\r\n\t<td>ר Resh</td>\r\n\t<td>&rho;</td></tr>\r\n<tr><td>Σ σ</td>\r\n\t<"..., ecode=0x81b5e53 "M", offset_top=4, md=0xbfffca50, ims=0, eptrb=0xbfea1838, flags=2) at /tmp/php-4.3.4/ext/pcre/pcrelib/pcre.c:5059 #11144 0x8082eb0 in match ( eptr=0x81b38fd ">\r\n\t<td>[[Rho]]</td>\r\n\t<td>[rO:]</td>\r\n\t<td>[ro]</td>\r\n\t<td> </td>\r\n\t<td>[r]</td>\r\n\t<td>[r]</td>\r\n\t<td>100</td>\r\n\t<td>ר Resh</td>\r\n\t<td>&rho;</td></tr>\r\n<tr><td>Σ σ</td>\r\n\t<"..., ecode=0x81b5e7e "?", offset_top=4, md=0xbfffca50, ims=0, eptrb=0xbfea1d18, flags=2) at /tmp/php-4.3.4/ext/pcre/pcrelib/pcre.c:5583 #11145 0x808236e in match ( eptr=0x81b38fc "d>\r\n\t<td>[[Rho]]</td>\r\n\t<td>[rO:]</td>\r\n\t<td>[ro]</td>\r\n\t<td> </td>\r\n\t<td>[r]</td>\r\n\t<td>[r]</td>\r\n\t<td>100</td>\r\n\t<td>ר Resh</td>\r\n\t<td>&rho;</td></tr>\r\n<tr><td>Σ σ</td>\r\n\t"..., ecode=0x81b5e53 "M", offset_top=4, md=0xbfffca50, ims=0, eptrb=0xbfea1d18, flags=2) at /tmp/php-4.3.4/ext/pcre/pcrelib/pcre.c:5059 #11146 0x8082eb0 in match ( eptr=0x81b38fc "d>\r\n\t<td>[[Rho]]</td>\r\n\t<td>[rO:]</td>\r\n\t<td>[ro]</td>\r\n\t<td> </td>\r\n\t<td>[r]</td>\r\n\t<td>[r]</td>\r\n\t<td>100</td>\r\n\t<td>ר Resh</td>\r\n\t<td>&rho;</td></tr>\r\n<tr><td>Σ σ</td>\r\n\t"..., ecode=0x81b5e7e "?", offset_top=4, md=0xbfffca50, ims=0, eptrb=0xbfea21f8, flags=2) at /tmp/php-4.3.4/ext/pcre/pcrelib/pcre.c:5583 #11147 0x808236e in match ( eptr=0x81b38fb "td>\r\n\t<td>[[Rho]]</td>\r\n\t<td>[rO:]</td>\r\n\t<td>[ro]</td>\r\n\t<td> </td>\r\n\t<td>[r]</td>\r\n\t<td>[r]</td>\r\n\t<td>100</td>\r\n\t<td>ר Resh</td>\r\n\t<td>&rho;</td></tr>\r\n<tr><td>Σ σ</td>\r\n"..., ecode=0x81b5e53 "M", offset_top=4, md=0xbfffca50, ims=0, eptrb=0xbfea21f8, flags=2) at /tmp/php-4.3.4/ext/pcre/pcrelib/pcre.c:5059 #11148 0x8082eb0 in match ( eptr=0x81b38fb "td>\r\n\t<td>[[Rho]]</td>\r\n\t<td>[rO:]</td>\r\n\t<td>[ro]</td>\r\n\t<td> </td>\r\n\t<td>[r]</td>\r\n\t<td>[r]</td>\r\n\t<td>100</td>\r\n\t<td>ר Resh</td>\r\n\t<td>&rho;</td></tr>\r\n<tr><td>Σ σ</td>\r\n"..., ecode=0x81b5e7e "?", offset_top=4, md=0xbfffca50, ims=0, eptrb=0xbfea26d8, And so on... You get the idea ------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=26469&edit=1
