ID: 48989 User updated by: lcoffin at cio dot com -Summary: --with-axps2 and --enable-embed incompatible Reported By: lcoffin at cio dot com Status: Bogus Bug Type: Unknown/Other Function Operating System: Ubuntu 8.04 PHP Version: 5.3.0 New Comment:
Sorry, I'm used to the "here's everything I want, now build it" kind of thinking -- i.e. "I want the CLI, the Apache module, and an embeddable library". This "rebuild for each use" isn't what I was expecting and seems *very* cumbersome to maintain -- I have to remember multiple sets of config options and each time I upgrade PHP I have to remember to configure/build each one. Having the ability to specify and build everything at once would be really handy. At the very least, configure should thow a warning if not a downright error when conflicting flags are given -- *something* to indicate it's not going to do what it's been asked to do. It would have saved me a *ton* of wasted time trying to figure this out. I'm old school enough -- I've worked with so many packages over the years that install things in the oddest of places -- that when I see that a package has built a 'libphp5.so' and I've got another package trying to link with -lphp5, I go looking for said 'libphp5.so' in the system... When I find it in an unexpected place (not in /lib, /usr/lib, etc.) I just assume the installer is "special" and decided to install it in its own special place so I create a sym link in the appropriate place for use with other packages. Perhaps it would make more sense to name the libraries appropriately? I.e. libphp5apxs.so, libphp5embed.so? I mean 'libphp5.so' should be *exactly* the same as 'libphp5.so' shouldn't it? libjpeg is libjpeg ... libperl is libperl. Anyway... just some thoughts... -L Previous Comments: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2009-07-21 12:59:42] j...@php.net You can't build multiple SAPIs. You're building an Apache SAPI here. --enable-embed is simply ignored. (alphabetical order, A comes before E :) ------------------------------------------------------------------------ [2009-07-20 16:13:16] lcoffin at cio dot com Description: ------------ If --with-apxs2 is included with --enable-embed then the resulting library can't be used with embedded applications. Trying to build an app (plphp-1.3.5 and plphp-1.3.3) that embeds PHP results in a number of lines like: /usr/local/lib/libphp5.so: undefined reference to `apr_brigade_create' /usr/local/lib/libphp5.so: undefined reference to `apr_bucket_eos_create' /usr/local/lib/libphp5.so: undefined reference to `apr_brigade_cleanup' /usr/local/lib/libphp5.so: undefined reference to `ap_auth_type' If --with-apxs2 is left off of the PHP build, the embedding app compiles just fine. Not sure if this is a bug per-se, or a problem with not including enough libraries (the apache libs?) when compiling the embedding app, or if there needs to be a check in ./configure that flags the invalid combination and doesn't allow ./configure to complete. But now I seem to be stuck with the problem of needing to have two "versions" of php -- compile once with --with-apxs2 and once with --enable-embed. And I'm not sure which one I should do first, which one I should do second, and what the implications are (i.e. if the CLI version of php needs to be one vs the other. Or if Apache will stop working if the --enable-embed one is the second compile.) Reproduce code: --------------- cd /usr/src/php-5.3.0 ./configure --with-apxs2="..." --enable-embed (other options) make && make install cd /usr/src/plphp-1.3.5/trunk ./configure (configure fails... config.log shows above errors) cd /usr/src/php-5.3.0 ./configure --enable-embed (other options) make && make install cd /usr/src/plphp-1.3.5/trunk ./configure (succeeds) Expected result: ---------------- Expected plphp/configure to succeed Actual result: -------------- plphp/configure fails with: /usr/local/lib/libphp5.so: undefined reference to `apr_brigade_create' /usr/local/lib/libphp5.so: undefined reference to `apr_bucket_eos_create' /usr/local/lib/libphp5.so: undefined reference to `apr_brigade_cleanup' /usr/local/lib/libphp5.so: undefined reference to `ap_auth_type' ... etc. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- Edit this bug report at http://bugs.php.net/?id=48989&edit=1
