Frank Theriault wrote:

"...if one is going to take the time to go beyond that and actually
say something meaningful about a photo, it's more meaningful to me if
it appears that they've actually put some thought into it, and express
themselves in a clear and cogent manner.  Part of that clear
communication is me thinking that they actually care about what
they're saying, and that part of what they're doing is trying to help
me work through something or give me advice."

I hope that's enough of the thread to put my comments in context. I
think it might be helpful for whoever submits the PESO or PAW to mention
what types of comments they're looking for. "Comments welcome" isn't
much to go on. If the submitter only wants to know if the shot works for
the viewer then I suggest that he ask for that type of comment. If the
submitter is looking for critiques then I suggest that they ask for that.

Tom Reese





Reply via email to