Rob Studdert wrote:
Technical and subjective aspects of an image can be commented upon independently and negative technicalities don't necessarily mean that an image is a write off. Suggestions that could lead to a better shot technically surely shouldn't be dismissed in favour of volumes of bloated and gratuitous praise?
I can't see any volumes of bloated and gratuitous praise in my previous message. The idea is that I got sick of nitpicking. If the photographer decides to get a Velvia look to her/his image, he'll obviously get some dense shadows and/or nearly burned highlights (unless he's shooting graycards), aggravated by subsequent scanning. He knows that we know that so why mentioning it every time.
I always get suspicious when no one has anything bad to say about my images.
I'll make sure you won't ever get suspicious again ;-)
cheers ! ;-)
