ppkarwasz commented on PR #351: URL: https://github.com/apache/logging-parent/pull/351#issuecomment-2743064601
I started a [thread on `dev@logging`](https://lists.apache.org/thread/8yw874zdjms3kbms0ld6qc799974wspj). > 1. Roles come and go. Why do we follow a role-based ordering? (Want to appear at the top?) I see the `<developers>` section as a prioritized contact list. The person to contact for the **latest** release is the PMC Chair, when his term is up, someone else takes his place. I don't have any evidence that the `<developers>` section was ever used to contact a developer or any other purpose, so this is pure speculation. > 2. My organization is not ASF and I don't want to use my `@apache.org` email address either. (WTF?) > 3. I want to point to my personal home page, not some ASF/GitHub facade. We probably should remove the organization everywhere. One of the reasons this is a draft, is to allow team members to recheck and update the data they provide. The e-mail and URL are "safe" default with a `-pom` suffix to the Apache e-mail to help identifying the source of the data. BTW: I didn't add your `@apache.org` e-mail in the POM file, it was already there. > 4. `adds all the active Apache Logging Services team members` Why? This is _"a subproject of ALS"_, not _"the ALS project"_. Why do we need to list here the name of individuals who never ever done anything for `logging-parent` and/or Log4j? If we list the people "responsible" for our artifacts, that list includes also Log4cxx and Log4net developers. Some Log4j releases were validated thanks to their votes. I think that this should not be a list of copyright holders or maintainers that are also copyright holders. We could retrieve such a list from Git, but it might be inaccurate. > I am fine with removing temporal `organization`, `roles`, `timezone` entries – this will pretty much ensure sustainability. Though I prefer to respect to author's choice of `id`, `name`, `email`, and `url`. I completely agree with you. This is a draft and it will not be merged unless people agree on their data. -- This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service. To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the URL above to go to the specific comment. To unsubscribe, e-mail: notifications-unsubscr...@logging.apache.org For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at: us...@infra.apache.org
