On 6/28/2016 8:57 AM, John Fastabend wrote:
On 16-06-27 09:07 AM, Saeed Mahameed wrote:
Add the commands to set and show the mode of SRIOV E-Switch, two modes are
supported:
* legacy : operating in the "old" L2 based mode (DMAC --> VF vport)
* offloads : offloading SW rules/policy (e.g Bridge/FDB or TC/Flows based) set
by the host OS
Nice work overall also I really appreciated that the core networking
interfaces appear to able to support this without any change.
thanks..
On this patch though do we really need modes like this? My concern with
modes is two fold. One its another knob that some controller will have
to get right which I would prefer to avoid. And two I suspect switching
between the two modes flushes the tables or leaves them in some
unexpected state? At least I can't figure out what the expected should
be off-hand.
Re the 1st concern (another knob), I think we do want that, see below
Re the 2nd concern, I will re-read the cover letter and change logs and
if needed clarify/improve: the transition is clean! When you are moving
from legacy to offloads or the other way around, nothing is left in
unexpected state, all HW forwarding tables as filled by the current
mode are flushed and next they are set as needed for the new mode.
Could we instead continue to use the "legacy" mode by default by just
populating the fdb table correctly and then if users want to enable
the "offloads" mode they can modify the fdb tables by deleting entries
or adding them or just extending the dmac/vf mapping via 'tc'. This
would seem natural to me. The flooding rules in fdb might need to be
exposed a bit more cleanly to get the right default flooding behavior
etc. But to me at least this would be much cleaner. Everything will be
nicely defined and we wont have issues with drivers doing slightly
and subtle different defaults between legacy/offload and the transitions
between the states or on resets or etc. If users need to discover the
current configuration then they just query fdb, query tc, and the state
is known no need for any magic toggle switch as best I can see.
Few comments here:
Each mode has it's own way of the driver doing setup for the HW tables
and how population of the HW tables is done.
The offloads mode needs to create a black hole miss rule and
send-to-vport rules and create the tables so they can contain later
rules set by the kernel in a way which is HW/driver dependent.
The legacy mode creates the tables differently and populates them later
with rule set by
the driver and not the kernel.
Even if we put the different table setup issue a side, I don't think it
would be correct for bridge/tc to remove rules they didn't add, which is
needed under your proposal when moving from legacy type rules to
offloads mode. Querying is problematic too, since legacy could (and
does) involve some default rules set by the FW, e.g that deals with
outer world (== not belonging to VM on this host) MACs which are
invisible to the driver.
That legacy was here and we can't avoid handling it properly for which
this knob is needed. Note that a vendor can choose to put their default
to be offloads, hopefully over time, we will all go there :)
Otherwise I didn't review the mlx code but read the commit msgs and
it looks good. I'll take a closer look in the morning.
appreciated
