On 17 Jun 2013, at 17:26, Luke Tracy wrote:

The listserv has now been converted to an MCommunity Group.

And was echoing every legitimate message for a day. Cute. Not very competent, but cute.

You can view
the details of the group here:
https://mcommunity.umich.edu/#group:ldap

Definitely not ready for production use. It has link syntax errors that would have been caught in the most trivial sort of testing, making it clear that was none. Also serve out an uncacheable 7.5 MB file that blocks rendering until it completes and consists of an atrocious mess of GWT-based JavaScript. That's simply user-hostile for anyone not on the UMich network, as it means a long wait (about a minute, at T-1 speed) with nothing renderable. Whoever created that system would do more good flipping burgers than designing webapps and writing code.

Beyond that, the site is displaying the full member list to anyone wandering by, all in unobfuscated mailto links, perfect for harvesters. You've apparently also opened submissions to the list to any sender, with a convenient mailto on the public web page. The inevitable result: the address I use for this list got its first spam in over 4 years, just 12 hours after you made the switch. It had 15 more tossed at it in 48 hours, all coming from UMich machines with [email protected] as the Return-Path. In short: you've made this a spam list.

The LDAP listserv is an open list and anyone may subscribe and
unsubscribe. I am therefore planning to make the MCommunity group joinable, however, only members with a University of Michigan login will be able to join or resign on their own. All others will need to request to join or
resign.

I have an easier method, thanks to having signed up with an address designed to be killed unilaterally. Never thought I'd have to use it because of bumbling incompetence at UMich, but glad to be able to stop some spam without counting on the people whose carelessness made it happen.

Reply via email to