Have you set up ofx logging?  That will show exactly what is being sent as the request, and sometimes give a more useful error message than what gets surfaced through the UI.

On 8/13/21 6:03 PM, Brendan Coupe wrote:
On Fri, Aug 13, 2021 at 3:06 PM Jack via KMyMoney-devel
<kmymoney-devel@kde.org> wrote:
On 8/13/21 4:40 PM, Brendan Coupe via KMyMoney-devel wrote:
[snip... and sorry for any strange formatting, I'm not using my usual email app]

I thought about that since importing CSV files from USAA into KMM is
annoying but it may not save me any time.  I may give it a try.

I should have asked if you can export OFX (sometimes call QFX) files from USAA. 
 That would be better than importing CSV.  However my suggestion (which may 
well not save any time) is doing a direct connect import to GnuCash, and then 
exporting from there to import into KMM.  Valid as a temporary workaround at 
best.
Unfortunately they do not offer anything but CSV.

I guess I wasn't clear. I tried mapping with both ofximporter and kbanking.  
kbanking was already setup since it uses the aqbanking settings that I got to 
work on GnuCash. The KMM crash happens when I attempt to import an account that 
was mapped with kbanking/aqbanking.

I tried expert mode (ofximporter) before my first email. I tried both
QMOFX and 2300 in the "Identify As" box. Both failed. Both appear to
be required in aqbanking but ofximporter only has one box to fill in.

 From the GnuCash instructions:
  Application ID       QMOFX
  Application Version  2300
  Header Version       103

Aha - in that single box, you need to put QMOFX:2300 - it combined the appid 
and version, separated by a colon.
QMOFX:2300 did not solve the problem. I suspect the bank needs to see
"HTTP User Agent:        InetClntApp/3.0" somewhere.

The exact same settings (QMOFX & 2300) in AqBanking work in GnuCash
but cause KMM to crash. Does AqBanking work normally, I've never tried
to use it before today.

We should certainly track down the cause of that crash, but getting you 
importing again is also good, if a separate goal.

Jack

Reply via email to