On Tue, 24 Sep 2013 22:44:09 +0100
David Houlden <djhoul...@gmail.com> wrote:
> On Tuesday 24 September 2013 13:28:47 aga wrote:
> > Hi Cristian (and interested others, please)
> >
> > On Tue, 24 Sep 2013 10:05:26 +0300
> >
> > Cristian Oneț <onet.crist...@gmail.com> wrote:
> > > 2013/9/23 aga <agande...@gmail.com>:
> > > [...]
> > >
> > > > If I open an existing reinvestdividend, which has an interest
> > > > category already entered, the interest amount box should open
> > > > and display the current amount. The amount box does not show.
> > > > This is both without and with your patches.
> > > >
> > > > Resizing the window enables the amount widget to show, but I
> > > > haven't yet found where it gets changed.
> >
> > I have this working correctly, now, however....
> >
> > > This is caused by the special handling of the reinvest action in
> > > InvestTransactionEditor::slotUpdateInterestVisibility which is
> > > incorrect. I guess even with a reinvest action the interest
> > > category-amount pair should work the same way like the fee
> > > category-amount pair (show the amount if the category is not
> > > empty).
> >
> > I've brought the reinvest handling in investactivities.cpp, into
> > line with the fee handling. There was some redundant code there,
> > where the functionality was already handled in
> > InvestTransactionEditor::slotUpdateInterestVisibility().
> >
> > > The code I just mentioned states that it tries do do one thing
> > > ("don't ever hide the label") but it breaks this behavior.
> >
> > I don't think that's the case really. I interpret it as
> > distinguishing between hiding a label and setting it to an empty
> > string, which is what is done. However, I've just hidden the
> > interest amount label and there's no apparent adverse effect.
> >
> > However, and I hope Dave Houlden and others may comment, I'm not
> > sure about the amount actually being displayed here. In a reinvest
> > dividend transaction, the dividend is used to purchase further
> > shares/units. At the moment, when a category has been entered for
> > the transaction, the Amount edit box also opens, which I think is
> > confusing as it seems like an invitation to the user to enter an
> > amount, when there should be no such amount, as the dividend has
> > been used for the purchase.
> >
> > What do others think?
> >
> > Allan
> >
> > > Regards,
> > > Cristian
>
> Hi Allan,
>
> I've not been following this one very closely so I'm a bit confused.
> Are you discussing the behaviour of git master or git master plus
> some patches (yours or Cristian's or both)?
>
> I certainly have reinvest dividend transactions where I enter both a
> fee and interest amount. The interest amount is the net dividend paid
> by the company. The fee amount is the charge they make for processing
> the reinvestment. Interest minus fee is the amount used to purchase
> shares.
>
> Could you please clarify what you want an opinion on and if I need
> the patch(es) to see the behaviour then let me know where they are.
> I'm more than happy to help.
>
> Dave.
Hi Dave
Apologies for not being clearer. No patches have as yet been
submitted, so no input needed from you in that area.
However, I'm in the process of developing a patch to get the columns to
set themselves to sensible values, where each column is made wide enough
for its data, with any additional window space given to the Details
column. This is instead of the current situation, where no individual
column may be resized, and, if someone has a need for a longish check
number, then the only recourse is to stretch the window, but that extra
space gets grabbed by the Detail column.
Anyway, during that there was some difficulty getting the edit widgets
to behave during a window resize. The most recent problem was with
reinvest transactions, and the presence or otherwise of the Interest
Amount widget. I began to wonder whether it should actually be
displayed. In the simple case, the dividend amount is the quantity of
shares x price. It's only necessary to add those details, and there is
no need for the interest amount field. If a fee is entered, that is
going to be deducted from the dividend amount, and presumably, is going
to affect the quantity of shares allocated. I'm assuming that your
incoming advice will give the correct actual quantity of shares, so you
enter that and the price and the fee, so there again is no need for any
entry in the interest field. The total field should reflect the true
allocated dividend.
So, if the actual quantity and price details are entered, and the fee,
then that is all that is needed. The interest field is redundant, and
no entry needs to be made. So for a reinvest it's not required and if
you make an entry, it doubles up the amount while the transaction is
open, but on saving the amount is correct.
A Dividend payment does require that field, however, and an account
needs to be entered to receive the money. In a Reinvest, there is no
money to be transferred so no asset-account field is displayed.
So, if you were able to follow that rambling, can you confirm, or
otherwise, that you are able to enter just the quantity, price and fee
and get the correct result.
If I'm still unclear, let me know.
Cheers
Allan
_______________________________________________
KMyMoney-devel mailing list
KMyMoney-devel@kde.org
https://mail.kde.org/mailman/listinfo/kmymoney-devel
