https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=439481
--- Comment #21 from Konstantin Kharlamov <hi-an...@yandex.ru> ---
(In reply to David Edmundson from comment #20)
> Because you're creating a within a system that covers something we have
> already only worse as it's via a propriety undocumented env var.

I might be missing something: I don't currently see a way to properly cover
replacing a WM while having Plasma systemd-boot enabled.  An approach that has
been suggested (here and on duplicates) is basically editing systemd-service
dependencies, so a custom WM is started instead of kwin_x11. There's a problem
though: that would render you unable to start Plasma with kwin anymore.

IOW, with the KDEWM-way documented on wiki (and on github, which I assume was
the original source) allows you to choose in SDDM between a "vanilla" Plasma
session with kwin and the custom one with i3wm/whatever-wm. The "edit
dependencies" approach requires you to hack around in a VTY if you wanted to
switch between the kwin and i3wm sessions. And no more nice GUI option for you.

> Turning the question around, if you were to build from scratch, why would
> choosing a WM go via an env var?

I see! So, what you're up against is specifically having the env. variable.
That means if we'd find a way to implement the functional with systemd but
without the variable, that might be accepted.

Okay. With that said, I don't currently have a solution to that problem. I'll
have to think, perhaps I'll figure something out.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are watching all bug changes.

Reply via email to