https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=438780

--- Comment #3 from leftcrane <leftcr...@tutanota.com> ---
You either have a different trackpoint or don't use it enough to notice. It's a
hardware issue with the lenovo trackpoints (it's just how the rubber gets
deformed and then gets back its former shape). But the fundamental point is
that accidental mouse movements should not interfere with the behavior of a
keyboard-based launcher.

This is clearly a KDE UX issue. Other GUIs never have this problem because they
sensibly separate keyboard input from mouse input, precisely to avoid this
issue. Don't believe me? Take a look at Chromium's omnibar. Move the mouse
there and press enter. It will still launch the entry you've selected with your
keyboard, irrespective of where the cursor happens to be. This is the logical
behavior and it's how other launchers behave too, thus avoiding the problem
entirely. They aren't wrong.

IF you remember, for ages Krunner would actually open whatever entry the mouse
was hovering over, even without movement. It was later partially "fixed" by
requiring movement, but the original design which was the actual source of the
problem was kept

The only consequence of KDE's design of mixing keyboard and mouse input is
unintended launches. Is causing accidental launches "intended behavior"? Cause
that's the only feature the current design provides. So please reconsider.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are watching all bug changes.

Reply via email to