https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=433404

--- Comment #3 from Nate Graham <n...@kde.org> ---
The behavior is totally consistent, but it's consistent with the actual reason
for double-click to exist.

The entire reason for double-click to exist is because certain things have a
state where they can be selected, and in that state, you can perform
non-opening actions on them. For such items, some people find it useful to
enter that selected state with one click, so they can perform actions on the
item without having to use a context menu. This is literally the only reason
for anything to ever be double-clickable.

Files and folders can be double-clickable because they have a state where they
can be selected, in which you can perform rename actions, copy actions, delete
actions, etc. Therefore it makes sense to offer an option for them to open on a
double-click, because some people prefer for the single-click action to be
"select this item" not "open this item."

These icons here in System Settings have no selection state in which it is
possible to perform any actions. You can't copy them. You can't email them to
someone else. You can't delete them. The only thing you can do with them is
open them. You can't rename them. The only thing you can do with them is open
them. There is only one action they perform.

What do you call a clickable UI element has exactly one action and only one
action that it can perform when interacted with? A button. And buttons never
have to be double-clicked to make them perform their action. They always
perform their action on the first click, even when you use the systemwide
double-click setting.

System Settings' icon view is a grid of buttons. The buttons may not look like
buttons, but that's not unusual; a ToolButton is a button that doesn't look
like a button. We use non-buttonlike buttons all over the place throughout KDE
software. This is personally not my favorite thing in the world, and if I had
my way, all buttons would have a visibly buttonlike appearance.

Alas, this is not the majority view, so I accept it. And because of that,
System Settings' Icon View is a grid of non-buttonlike buttons. So they open
their KCMs on a single-click, just like all other buttons to.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are watching all bug changes.

Reply via email to