https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=413709

--- Comment #3 from TigerShark <ties...@yahoo.com.ar> ---
First time I hear about fish shell. Will give it a try.

Didn't understand the related PR. Setting that history to 0 would disable the
auto completion?
If so, it could function as some kind of workaround I guess.

I might be repeating myself but let me go over the idea again.

I'm in no way against offering auto-completion, just against suggestions being
automatically "accepted" and searched for without user confirmation by pressing
Tab (or right arrow maybe).


Automatically searching for suggestions saves the user exactly 1 keystroke
(tab|→) when the suggestion is what the user actually intended. 

On the other hand, it forces the user to input 1 or more characters to
"correct" every wrong suggestion. 
Given krunner can search in a lot of places, I dare to say the probability of
several entries having matching starts is high. That in turn means the average
amount of keystrokes needed to correct the auto-completion suggestion will be
higher or equal to just typing a bare minimum and then pressing down|down|down
to get to the correct entry. I guess the mental effort to check the
auto-completion is right is not less than the required to find that the 4th
entry in the list is the correct one.

Ofc I don't have the data to back this up, just my personal experience and
observations.



Ideally, I would expect krunner to search for what I explicitly type. Results
are sorted by whatever history count (or machine learning?) algorithm u
currently use, but with a setting to force use alphabetical order (no idea if
this already exists). Auto completion requires a tab press to apply its
suggestion and update the search query.

Thx for your interest in this report ;)

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are watching all bug changes.

Reply via email to